It's not very easy to slit a tyre in the process of fitting (tube yes, tyre no), so it may well have been faulty. You'll probably get a refund if you say you fitted it normally then immediately discovered the slit.
Uneven seating of a tyre is a common little problem, and if you're lucky will correct itself when the tyre is refitted and fully inflated, but sometimes it may never be quite right (not that you'd notice a small error when riding). Hopefully your Contis will be better anyway.