I'm loving my shimano rt4 touring shoes for winter riding. No mesh, no vent holes, just sensible walkable shoes. Not sure if it's the lace up closure or if the last is genuinely different from the roadie range of shimano shoes, but they fit me OK in spite of the fact that I normally require a wide fitting shoe. The latter just means more room for cosy socks if you don't have wide feet.
In fact, as someone who always suffered from cold feet, these in winter and Giro Factor ACC HV shoes in summer (perforated uppers, but very small holes and no mesh) has been one of a handful of cycling revelations in the last year or so that I can't believe I didn't suss years ago.