Yet Another Cycling Forum

General Category => The Knowledge => Ctrl-Alt-Del => Topic started by: Tim Hall on 20 April, 2021, 09:40:48 am

Title: Google account birthday request
Post by: Tim Hall on 20 April, 2021, 09:40:48 am
My new! shiny! Android phone , which is signed into my Google account, has just flashed up a Google message:
"Your date of is missing. This info is needed to comply with the law"

Now Google probably know more about me than I do, but the "comply with the law" wording is increadibly shite and vague. A swift [mode=irony] Google [/mode] suggests the account might get zapped if I don't add my dob. I can't find which particular law they're referring to.

Shoulds I just comply or die on this digital hill?
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Jaded on 20 April, 2021, 09:42:55 am
Do what i do, put your birthday in as 1 Jan on a year close to yours.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: hubner on 20 April, 2021, 09:44:44 am
I use 1 Jan 1900, easy to remember.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: rogerzilla on 20 April, 2021, 09:57:06 am
Don't put anything too young, or it will.probably block access to email, social media and possibly red hot XXX Audax sites.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: citoyen on 20 April, 2021, 10:09:35 am
Don't put anything too young, or it will.probably block access to email, social media and possibly red hot XXX Audax sites.

Tim "Barely Legal" Hall  ;D
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Mr Larrington on 20 April, 2021, 10:24:47 am
If it really omits the word “birth” from the message I'd say you had bigger problems than upsetting the Chocolate Factory.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Polar Bear on 20 April, 2021, 02:15:49 pm
I wonder just how many people in webland have a birthday including the first of the month?    Pretty high proportion I should imagine.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: hellymedic on 20 April, 2021, 07:17:28 pm
ISTR that includes your good self PB...
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Lightning Phil on 20 April, 2021, 07:58:35 pm
There is no such law requiring them to have your DOB.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: hubner on 20 April, 2021, 08:04:17 pm
Maybe it's USA/NSA/CIA law.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: philip on 20 April, 2021, 08:10:26 pm
Yes, the USA's COPPA act requires companies to have parental consent to collect personal information on children under 13.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 20 April, 2021, 08:28:50 pm
There's also that weird thing with booze sites that makes you put in you DoB to confirm that you're over eighteen.

I figure the kids have that one sorted, though I think licking the screen will be marginally less effective than drinking 24 cans of Top Deck Shandy, something that from experience I don't recommend.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Little Jim on 20 April, 2021, 08:51:34 pm
There's also that weird thing with booze sites that makes you put in you DoB to confirm that you're over eighteen.

I figure the kids have that one sorted, though I think licking the screen will be marginally less effective than drinking 24 cans of Top Deck Shandy, something that from experience I don't recommend.

Whereas our local artisan beer emporium just asks if you are over 18 with two options to click on.  Perhaps the kids around here are a bit thick.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Feanor on 20 April, 2021, 09:00:06 pm
Years ago, I got caught out when we got a PS3 for the kids.
In order to play online, I needed to create accounts for them.

If I was honest about their DoB, they needed to be subsidiary accounts to mine.
This just didn't work: The games just didn't work. And I'm not talking about nasty stuff here.
So I created fake accounts for them with aged-up DoBs.
But I had to create new e-mail addresses on my domain for that, because the existing e-mail addresses were tied to the Junior accounts forever, and nothing I could do could jailbreak them.

And now, I can't remember the fake DoBs I used, and can't find where I recorded it, so I'm locked out of those accounts too!
I thought I'd used their actual DoB, but with my Year of Birth substituted.

FFS!
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: drossall on 20 April, 2021, 09:06:13 pm
I also have an Internet birthday that is different from my real birthday. This results in lots of good wishes on 1 January from people who don't know me well enough to spot the discrepancy ;D

It would be unusual for a law to say that a company must know your birthday, especially as birthdays get used in identity theft and are therefore confidential information. Usually, it goes like this:
"You must tell us your date of birth" is therefore short-hand for "We are required to get evidence of your age, and that's what we've chosen". Arguments that DoB does not provide very strong evidence (which it doesn't), or that it's an invasion of privacy, will fall on deaf ears. But it remains untrue that the law requires them to ask DoB, because the law establishes a principle of a need to make reasonable checks, and leaves it to individual companies to work out what those should be.

In practice, of course, they might just as well ask "Are you over 18", since that would provide evidence nearly as strong. The only additional evidence provided by asking DoB is that the subject is able to do maths well enough to invent a date that actually is more than 18 years ago.

Strictly, if they tell you that the DoB is for a security check, and then additionally use it for other reasons, such as to target you with age-appropriate products or even send you birthday wishes, that's a breach of GDPR, which requires them to declare the reasons for which they will use the information, and then limit themselves to those.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 20 April, 2021, 09:12:56 pm
There's also that weird thing with booze sites that makes you put in you DoB to confirm that you're over eighteen.

I figure the kids have that one sorted, though I think licking the screen will be marginally less effective than drinking 24 cans of Top Deck Shandy, something that from experience I don't recommend.

Whereas our local artisan beer emporium just asks if you are over 18 with two options to click on.  Perhaps the kids around here are a bit thick.

I think it's a hangover from the US, all the shops there have the if you're born after this date in whatever year, you can buy booze and cigarettes (in those states where there's still a state monopoly of boozohol, I think they're often the law, you buy them from the booze authority).

I figure this means that most Americans do not know how old they are, or that they really have been counting the days till they get their paws on their first legal forty-ouncer. Possibly both.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: citoyen on 20 April, 2021, 09:13:26 pm
In practice, of course, they might just as well ask "Are you over 18", since that would provide evidence nearly as strong. The only additional evidence provided by asking DoB is that the subject is able to do maths well enough to invent a date that actually is more than 18 years ago.

I was doing that to get served in pubs back when the www wasn’t even yet a glint in Sir Tim’s eye.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: mrcharly-YHT on 20 April, 2021, 09:26:15 pm
I think it's a hangover from the US, all the shops there have the if you're born after this date in whatever year, you can buy booze and cigarettes (in those states where there's still a state monopoly of boozohol, I think they're often the law, you buy them from the booze authority).

Only if they don't suspect that you might drink alcohol in order to get inebriated.

If you seem to be purchasing enough booze to get hammered, they might refuse to sell it to you.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 20 April, 2021, 09:57:57 pm
In practice, of course, they might just as well ask "Are you over 18", since that would provide evidence nearly as strong. The only additional evidence provided by asking DoB is that the subject is able to do maths well enough to invent a date that actually is more than 18 years ago.
Not always 18 though. Different minimum ages for different things and different places and occasionally varying by other factors, such as your sex or even your date of birth (see example below).

I think it's a hangover from the US, all the shops there have the if you're born after this date in whatever year, you can buy booze and cigarettes (in those states where there's still a state monopoly of boozohol, I think they're often the law, you buy them from the booze authority).
In a twist on this, NZ is considering a law to make it illegal for anyone born after 2004 to buy tobacco. Ever. "Smoke-free generation". https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/the-detail/300282141/tobacco-ban-for-those-born-after-2004--smokefree-generation-plan
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 20 April, 2021, 10:01:20 pm
I'm disappointed that no one's suggested changing your Google birthday several times a year so as to get multiple birthday presents.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Feanor on 20 April, 2021, 10:46:16 pm
There's also that weird thing with booze sites that makes you put in you DoB to confirm that you're over eighteen.

I figure the kids have that one sorted, though I think licking the screen will be marginally less effective than drinking 24 cans of Top Deck Shandy, something that from experience I don't recommend.

Whereas our local artisan beer emporium just asks if you are over 18 with two options to click on.  Perhaps the kids around here are a bit thick.

I think it's a hangover from the US, all the shops there have the if you're born after this date in whatever year, you can buy booze and cigarettes (in those states where there's still a state monopoly of boozohol, I think they're often the law, you buy them from the booze authority).

I figure this means that most Americans do not know how old they are, or that they really have been counting the days till they get their paws on their first legal forty-ouncer. Possibly both.

I had this bizarre thing in the local Co-Op a few weeks ago...

Junior ( age:21 ) and I went around the shop and picked up this and that.
At the checkout, I asked for a bottle of gin that was behind the counter.
'I need to see ID for junior', in case you are buying it for him.
We don't have such ID, so can't buy.

Purchase other items, go to car, return to shop myself one minute later, purchase gin from same person, just fine.




Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: arabella on 20 April, 2021, 11:17:56 pm
They're a bit paranoid.
I went to co-op with my mid teens son.  Being a strapping youngster he carried the basket.  Into which I put a 330ml bottle of beer for my own consumption, plus assorted commestibles of the veg/pasta/biscuit/etc variety.
Denied sale as my son had carried the basket.
Apparently looking at/taling about the merits of/anything remotely like that wrt alcohol is verboten.  So you could be really irritating, turn up with your offspring, talk them through the merits or otherwise of assorted beers/ciders/wines/etc and then not buy any.
(last time I looked which was admittedly a long time ago, you were allowed to buy beer (or porter) in pubs for 14yo anyway, so long as said 14yo stayed out of the bar area (where the carpet isn't).  Though that's probably no longer true.)

As regards GPDR etc, I had to fill in a customer form, for an email-type query.  They still wanted address, postcode and phone no, in addition to email address.  So I added to the form that they did not have my permission to use said unnecessary data which I had provided only because the form demanded it.  Someone will doubtless be along shortly to tell me such a statement has no standing.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Mr Larrington on 20 April, 2021, 11:23:46 pm
USAnia is strange.  My chum Auré, who is about 6’5” long and hav a huge hary beard, got asked for ID when he tried to order a BEER with his dinner.  At the time he was at least 30.  Perhaps it's coz he's French.  I am not quite as tall, nor was I so extravagantly furry, when I got carded for a similar “crime” in New Mexico, though I was only a few months shy of my fortieth.  And the cashier couldn’t understand the d.o.b. field on either a BRITISH passport or driving licence.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 21 April, 2021, 12:12:19 am
And the cashier couldn’t understand the d.o.b. field on either a BRITISH passport or driving licence.

Ha!  I hadn't considered that problem.

Mind you, after too long communing with the babbage-engines, I've been known to reach a state where I can make a reasonable guess at what a unisex spaceadmin timestamp might mean, but have to pull my BRANES out, blow into the edge connector and shove it back in a couple of times before I understand BRITISH dates.  This is probably what it feels like to be Excel.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: FifeingEejit on 21 April, 2021, 12:30:58 am
I had this bizarre thing in the local Co-Op a few weeks ago...

Junior ( age:21 ) and I went around the shop and picked up this and that.
At the checkout, I asked for a bottle of gin that was behind the counter.
'I need to see ID for junior', in case you are buying it for him.
We don't have such ID, so can't buy.

Purchase other items, go to car, return to shop myself one minute later, purchase gin from same person, just fine.

Presumably it's because they could possibly potentially etc. knowingly be selling the alcohol to be supplied to a bairn due to that bairns presence.

Quote from: Bits of Licensing 2005 (Scotland)
107Unsupervised sale of alcohol by a child or young person
(1)Any responsible person who F8... allows alcohol to be sold, supplied or served by a child or young person on any relevant premises commits an offence.


108Delivery of alcohol by or to a child or young person
(1)This section applies where alcohol is sold on any relevant premises for consumption off the premises.
(2)Any responsible person who allows the alcohol to be delivered by a child or young person commits an offence.
(3)Any responsible person who—
(a)delivers the alcohol, or
(b)allows it to be delivered,to a child or young person commits an offence.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Gattopardo on 21 April, 2021, 12:55:37 am
I use 1 Jan 1900, easy to remember.
or 1st february 1934....1234
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Mr Larrington on 21 April, 2021, 12:58:01 am
And the cashier couldn’t understand the d.o.b. field on either a BRITISH passport or driving licence.

Ha!  I hadn't considered that problem.

Mind you, after too long communing with the babbage-engines, I've been known to reach a state where I can make a reasonable guess at what a unisex spaceadmin timestamp might mean, but have to pull my BRANES out, blow into the edge connector and shove it back in a couple of times before I understand BRITISH dates.  This is probably what it feels like to be Excel.

No matter what the date format, my birthday is on the 13th and even in USAnia there are only twelve months.  It'd be pretty hard to interpret “64” as anything other than a year too.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: chrisbainbridge on 21 April, 2021, 06:38:55 am
The discrepancy between U.K. and USA dates came in very useful a couple of years ago when I wanted to hire a car. The license I realised standing in The queue had expired on 11/1/2018. This was now September. The agent looked at the license, reminded me that I needed to get it renewed before November and gave me the keys.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 21 April, 2021, 08:12:51 am
(last time I looked which was admittedly a long time ago, you were allowed to buy beer (or porter) in pubs for 14yo anyway, so long as said 14yo stayed out of the bar area (where the carpet isn't).  Though that's probably no longer true.)
I remember something similar but thought it included cider and the age was 16. I expect the correct version can be produced by combining both our memories, mixing them together, then throwing the result away and consulting the relevant legislation!
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Polar Bear on 21 April, 2021, 09:48:29 am
ISTR that includes your good self PB...

Indeed it does.  🙂

I am expecting a parcel today.  I'll keep you informed. 
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 21 April, 2021, 10:03:26 am
And the cashier couldn’t understand the d.o.b. field on either a BRITISH passport or driving licence.

Ha!  I hadn't considered that problem.

Mind you, after too long communing with the babbage-engines, I've been known to reach a state where I can make a reasonable guess at what a unisex spaceadmin timestamp might mean, but have to pull my BRANES out, blow into the edge connector and shove it back in a couple of times before I understand BRITISH dates.  This is probably what it feels like to be Excel.

No matter what the date format, my birthday is on the 13th and even in USAnia there are only twelve months.  It'd be pretty hard to interpret “64” as anything other than a year too.

I have honestly been asked by a lady scrutinizing the 28 in my DoB 'what month is that supposed to be?'
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: nuttycyclist on 21 April, 2021, 10:46:29 am
There's also that weird thing with booze sites that makes you put in you DoB to confirm that you're over eighteen.

I figure the kids have that one sorted, though I think licking the screen will be marginally less effective than drinking 24 cans of Top Deck Shandy, something that from experience I don't recommend.

Whereas our local artisan beer emporium just asks if you are over 18 with two options to click on.  Perhaps the kids around here are a bit thick.

I think it's a hangover from the US, all the shops there have the if you're born after this date in whatever year, you can buy booze and cigarettes (in those states where there's still a state monopoly of boozohol, I think they're often the law, you buy them from the booze authority).

I figure this means that most Americans do not know how old they are, or that they really have been counting the days till they get their paws on their first legal forty-ouncer. Possibly both.

I had this bizarre thing in the local Co-Op a few weeks ago...

Junior ( age:21 ) and I went around the shop and picked up this and that.
At the checkout, I asked for a bottle of gin that was behind the counter.
'I need to see ID for junior', in case you are buying it for him.
We don't have such ID, so can't buy.

Purchase other items, go to car, return to shop myself one minute later, purchase gin from same person, just fine.

I've not had issues in my supermarket, got a laugh even, when at the self service checkout my three year old scanned all the shopping, the boozeahol, and then paid with the contactless credit card.  Checkout supervisor was more than happy to click the "over 18" button and not ask for ID. 
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 21 April, 2021, 11:31:28 am
My wife got carded going into a taproom the last time we in NYC. She was very happy about this, me less so, since – despite her pathetic denials – she was clearly flirting with the doorman.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 21 April, 2021, 12:03:35 pm
And the cashier couldn’t understand the d.o.b. field on either a BRITISH passport or driving licence.

Ha!  I hadn't considered that problem.

Mind you, after too long communing with the babbage-engines, I've been known to reach a state where I can make a reasonable guess at what a unisex spaceadmin timestamp might mean, but have to pull my BRANES out, blow into the edge connector and shove it back in a couple of times before I understand BRITISH dates.  This is probably what it feels like to be Excel.

No matter what the date format, my birthday is on the 13th and even in USAnia there are only twelve months.  It'd be pretty hard to interpret “64” as anything other than a year too.

I have honestly been asked by a lady scrutinizing the 28 in my DoB 'what month is that supposed to be?'

Geldof, obviously.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Bledlow on 21 April, 2021, 12:10:13 pm
The discrepancy between U.K.world and USA dates came in very useful a couple of years ago when I wanted to hire a car. The license I realised standing in The queue had expired on 11/1/2018. This was now September. The agent looked at the license, reminded me that I needed to get it renewed before November and gave me the keys.
FTFY.  ;)
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 21 April, 2021, 12:10:42 pm
And the cashier couldn’t understand the d.o.b. field on either a BRITISH passport or driving licence.

Ha!  I hadn't considered that problem.

Mind you, after too long communing with the babbage-engines, I've been known to reach a state where I can make a reasonable guess at what a unisex spaceadmin timestamp might mean, but have to pull my BRANES out, blow into the edge connector and shove it back in a couple of times before I understand BRITISH dates.  This is probably what it feels like to be Excel.

No matter what the date format, my birthday is on the 13th and even in USAnia there are only twelve months.  It'd be pretty hard to interpret “64” as anything other than a year too.

I have honestly been asked by a lady scrutinizing the 28 in my DoB 'what month is that supposed to be?'

Geldof, obviously.

I told her it was the Julien calendar.

This sort of thing gets me into trouble, and why I spent years as a South African (owing to some accent misunderstanding in a local bar, I became South African, which after the joke ran out, persisted as he wouldn't believe I wasn't South African).
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: drossall on 21 April, 2021, 01:33:59 pm
I have always thought that the "British" format is more logical, as it at least goes from lesser (day) to greater (year) in a logical progression. Why would you start in the middle with month? I also read somewhere once that the "British" format is more international, in that the "US" one is really confined to the USA and Canada and ours is used elsewhere.

However, neither is satisfactory anywhere likely to be read internationally, since neither gives an unambiguous result, unlike various alternatives, such as 01-Jun-2021 or 2021-06-01 (which no-one reads as YYYY-DD-MM).
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 21 April, 2021, 01:43:04 pm
Americans always write April 21st and never 21st April, so I guess the format reflects that. It's totally illogical and a big PITA.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 21 April, 2021, 01:43:12 pm
I have always thought that the "British" format is more logical, as it at least goes from lesser (day) to greater (year) in a logical progression.

Little-endian is silly, but at least it's consistent.


Quote
Why would you start in the middle with month?

Historical reasons, presumably, from a time when dates were thought of as wordy things rather than numerical.  Middle-endian is the most stupid way of formatting a date.  (Which is where the BRITISH date format falls down - our dates are little-endian but our times are big-endian, so it becomes a mess when you put them together[1].)


Quote
However, neither is satisfactory anywhere likely to be read internationally, since neither gives an unambiguous result, unlike various alternatives, such as 01-Jun-2021 or 2021-06-01 (which no-one reads as YYYY-DD-MM).

Indeed.  ISO date is clearly the best if it's ever going anywhere near a computer.  Big-endian dates sort properly in ASCIIbetical order.  Pretty-print with a three-letter month and four digit year so that older humans immediately understand the format, assuming they understand the language of the month abbreviations used.

Internally, machines are much better off counting the number of time units from some epoch or other.  Less to go wrong.


[1] Obviously post-brexit we should insist that all timestamps are written 231.45:44:13T21-04-2021.  GMT, obviously, none of this UTC rubbish.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: citoyen on 21 April, 2021, 01:49:48 pm
Big-endian dates sort properly in ASCIIbetical order.

This FTW.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: chrisbainbridge on 21 April, 2021, 02:17:44 pm
Medical research dates will always put the month in letters rather than numbers to remove ambiguity
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 21 April, 2021, 02:43:24 pm
I like those formats which combine digits with either letters or Roman numerals: 21-IV-2021 or 21-APR-2021. You can put those in any order and it's clear, at least as long as you use a four-digit year (which of course, you sometimes won't).

Middle endian at least replicates common speech patterns: April the twenty-first. As for any of these systems being worldwide (or worldwide apart from USA), that kind of assumes that any calendar is worldwide.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: MikeFromLFE on 21 April, 2021, 03:40:58 pm


I like those formats which combine digits with either letters or Roman numerals: 21-IV-2021 or 21-APR-2021. You can put those in any order and it's clear, at least as long as you use a four-digit year (which of course, you sometimes won't).
My school, having pretentious to what it once had been, insisted we use roman numerals for the month. The only time I still do that, for reasons I can't explain, is X for October.


Sent from my moto g(30) using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 21 April, 2021, 05:06:39 pm
I like those formats which combine digits with either letters or Roman numerals: 21-IV-2021 or 21-APR-2021. You can put those in any order and it's clear, at least as long as you use a four-digit year (which of course, you sometimes won't).
My school, having pretentious to what it once had been, insisted we use roman numerals for the month. The only time I still do that, for reasons I can't explain, is X for October.

I think this is the first time I've come across it.   ???

I only use two-digit years when forced to by form fields.  The idea is approximately as abhorrent as putting punctuation inside the quote marks, for broadly similar reasons.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 21 April, 2021, 05:15:55 pm
I punctuate inside the quotes.

I do write out month names, on account of regularly communicating with Americans. It's also true that they genuinely cannot do 'military time.' (I'm sort of hoping the US military can do it.)
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Mr Larrington on 21 April, 2021, 06:08:47 pm
I punctuate inside the quotes.

I do write out month names, on account of regularly communicating with Americans. It's also true that they genuinely cannot do 'military time.' (I'm sort of hoping the US military can do it.)

AND they don’t have fortnights.  Even just saying the word sends them into paroxysms of helpless mirth.  “He said 'fortnight' snk snk splort lolz0rz &, moreover, roffle!”
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 21 April, 2021, 06:21:22 pm
I like those formats which combine digits with either letters or Roman numerals: 21-IV-2021 or 21-APR-2021. You can put those in any order and it's clear, at least as long as you use a four-digit year (which of course, you sometimes won't).
My school, having pretentious to what it once had been, insisted we use roman numerals for the month. The only time I still do that, for reasons I can't explain, is X for October.

I think this is the first time I've come across it.   ???
I think it's common in France and some other parts of ABROAD. And, it seems, pretentious English schools, who presumably like the idea of using something LATIN.

Quote
I only use two-digit years when forced to by form fields.  The idea is approximately as abhorrent as putting punctuation inside the quote marks, for broadly similar reasons.
I punctuate inside the quotes.
I punctuate inside or outside, depending on the preferences of whoever is paying me.  :D

Quote
I do write out month names, on account of regularly communicating with Americans. It's also true that they genuinely cannot do 'military time.' (I'm sort of hoping the US military can do it.)
'Military time' would be 24-hour clock? US military form would suggest they probably use a 'decimal 12-hour clock' or some such oxymoronic abomination.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: SteveC on 21 April, 2021, 06:23:25 pm
AND they don’t have fortnights.
Nor surnames
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 21 April, 2021, 06:25:17 pm
Oh, forgot about two-digit years. It's pleasing to read an early 20th century book in which characters reminisce about things that happened back in '88, for instance.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: drossall on 21 April, 2021, 06:34:31 pm
AND they don’t have fortnights.
How do they manage with the computer game? Which I've never played, and about which I know nothing.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 21 April, 2021, 08:00:54 pm
'Military time' would be 24-hour clock? US military form would suggest they probably use a 'decimal 12-hour clock' or some such oxymoronic abomination.

Yes, it's the 24-hour system. You can't even explain it to them, they have some kind of mental teflon against the concept. Put 1400 in an email and they'll be 'is that military time? I can't do that.' You can try telling them it's just a case of counting to twelve – noon – and then keep going. Nothing.

I wouldn't mind so much, but they also often can't get 12 am/pm correct.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 21 April, 2021, 08:45:06 pm
I wouldn't mind so much, but they also often can't get 12 am/pm correct.
Nobody can. Neither of them can be correct. As Wikipedia says:
Quote
It is not always clear what times "12:00 a.m." and "12:00 p.m." denote. From the Latin words meridies (midday), ante (before) and post (after), the term ante meridiem (a.m.) means before midday and post meridiem (p.m.) means after midday. Since "noon" (midday, meridies (m.)) is neither before nor after itself, the terms a.m. and p.m. do not apply.[2] Although "12 m." was suggested as a way to indicate noon, this is seldom done[20] and also does not resolve the question of how to indicate midnight.

The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language states "By convention, 12 AM denotes midnight and 12 PM denotes noon. Because of the potential for confusion, it is advisable to use 12 noon and 12 midnight."[24]

E. G. Richards in his book Mapping Time provided a diagram in which 12 a.m. means noon and 12 p.m. means midnight.[25]

The style manual of the United States Government Printing Office used 12 a.m. for noon and 12 p.m. for midnight until its 2008 edition, when it reversed these designations[17][18] and then retained that change in its 2016 revision.[26]

Many U.S. style guides, and NIST's "Frequently asked questions (FAQ)" web page,[2] recommend that it is clearest if one refers to "noon" or "12:00 noon" and "midnight" or "12:00 midnight" (rather than to "12:00 p.m." and "12:00 a.m."). The NIST website states that "12 a.m. and 12 p.m. are ambiguous and should not be used."

The Associated Press Stylebook specifies that midnight "is part of the day that is ending, not the one that is beginning."[23]

The Canadian Press Stylebook[21] says, "write noon or midnight, not 12 noon or 12 midnight." Phrases such as "12 a.m." and "12 p.m." are not mentioned at all. Britain's National Physical Laboratory "FAQ-Time" web page[22] states "In cases where the context cannot be relied upon to place a particular event, the pair of days straddling midnight can be quoted"; also "the terms 12 a.m. and 12 p.m. should be avoided."

Likewise, some U.S. style guides recommend either clarifying "midnight" with other context clues, such as specifying the two dates between which it falls, or not referring to the term at all. For an example of the latter method, "midnight" is replaced with "11:59 p.m." for the end of a day or "12:01 a.m." for the start of a day. That has become common in the United States in legal contracts and for airplane, bus, or train schedules, though some schedules use other conventions. Occasionally, when trains run at regular intervals, the pattern may be broken at midnight by displacing the midnight departure one or more minutes, such as to 11:59 p.m. or 12:01 a.m.[27]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/12-hour_clock#:~:text=The%20American%20Heritage%20Dictionary%20of,12%20noon%20and%2012%20midnight."

Similarly, is midnight 00:00 or 24:00? It's a different case, because both are correct rather than neither, and more importantly because whichever you use, it's not confusing (except to Americans).
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 21 April, 2021, 08:51:04 pm
Similarly, is midnight 00:00 or 24:00? It's a different case, because both are correct rather than neither, and more importantly because whichever you use, it's not confusing (except to Americans).

Indeed, you occasionally see people counting to 24 and keeping going, when it makes more sense to associate the post-midnight time with the previous day in timetables or similar.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 21 April, 2021, 08:56:10 pm
Yeah, whatever system you use, at some point you've got to stop and start again from whatever your starting point is. I suppose times like 24:30 make sense by analogy with 12:30 though. And in any case there are times which don't need naming unless you're 1) doing a critical 24/7 job, 2) wandering home pissed, 3) an audaxer, and even then it's only option 1 that really needs to know them.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 21 April, 2021, 08:59:16 pm
I think I first encountered it in an old Japanese TV guide in some film or other, where they kept counting until the end of the night's programming.  Having previously fallen foul of bus timetables rolling over from Friday to Saturday, it struck me as an eminently sensible idea.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 21 April, 2021, 09:23:52 pm
This reminds me of something I saw in a Victorian travel guide type thingy (not to a particular place), where there was a section on 'When the day begin in different parts of the word?' The possibilities included midnight, midday, sunrise, sunset and a couple of others I can't remember right now. All pretty obvious really though and just as relevant today. 'When you wake up' would be my suggestion.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: drossall on 21 April, 2021, 10:14:21 pm
I wouldn't mind so much, but they also often can't get 12 am/pm correct.
Can you get those correct? am is ante meridian (before midday) and pm is post meridian (after midday), so 12 hours before and after midday both mean midnight. Or, more reasonably, neither time exists, and we go from 11.59am to 12 noon to 12.01pm, and similarly 11.59pm, 12 midnight, 12.01 am. Certainly 12am is not a term I would ever use, because it's not clear what it means.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: ian on 21 April, 2021, 10:22:44 pm
12 pm is noon. Law. 12 am is midnight. Law. You fight the law. The law wins.

You can’t have a time that doesn’t exist or you’d fall into it.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 22 April, 2021, 12:47:56 am
On our cooker's display noon is 12:00 and midnight is 0:00.

Programmer had a brainfart remembering how 12 hour clocks are supposed to work?  I'm assuming it's not a 24 hour one, or it wouldn't be worthy of mention...

(Actually, I may have made that mistake in some code I wrote a while back, will have to check...)
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 22 April, 2021, 12:55:06 am
Actually, I may have made that mistake in some code I wrote a while back, will have to check...

 :facepalm:  Easily done.  Only barbarians and dyslexics use 12 hour clocks.

(click to show/hide)

Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: hellymedic on 22 April, 2021, 01:38:41 am
Medical research dates will always put the month in letters rather than numbers to remove ambiguity

I moved between England & Scotland and back, eventually registering with a GP after each move. My medical records failed to materialise, which I couldn't quite understand.

Eventually it transpired that my DoB of ** Jun **** had been misread as ** Jan ****.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: JonBuoy on 22 April, 2021, 07:27:46 am
This reminds me of something I saw in a Victorian travel guide type thingy (not to a particular place), where there was a section on 'When the day begin in different parts of the word?' The possibilities included midnight, midday, sunrise, sunset and a couple of others I can't remember right now. All pretty obvious really though and just as relevant today. 'When you wake up' would be my suggestion.

The Met Office website has an offset for their 'Maximum daytime temperature' and 'Minimum nighttime temperature' headline figures.  The figures for here for today are 14 degrees max and 2 degrees min.  The maximum is fair enough but it is currently zero and has been for some time - the minimum quoted is actually for 0600 tomorrow morning.

I am not sure what they do on one of those occasions where it warms up overnight rather than cooling down.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: perpetual dan on 22 April, 2021, 08:02:51 am
...

AND they don’t have fortnights.  Even just saying the word sends them into paroxysms of helpless mirth.  “He said 'fortnight' snk snk splort lolz0rz &, moreover, roffle!”

I work with USAnians and describing a meeting as “bi weekly” feels designed to confuse. Our project resolved this issue by finding that once a fortnight was too infrequent.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 22 April, 2021, 08:56:59 am
This reminds me of something I saw in a Victorian travel guide type thingy (not to a particular place), where there was a section on 'When the day begin in different parts of the word?' The possibilities included midnight, midday, sunrise, sunset and a couple of others I can't remember right now. All pretty obvious really though and just as relevant today. 'When you wake up' would be my suggestion.

The Met Office website has an offset for their 'Maximum daytime temperature' and 'Minimum nighttime temperature' headline figures.  The figures for here for today are 14 degrees max and 2 degrees min.  The maximum is fair enough but it is currently zero and has been for some time - the minimum quoted is actually for 0600 tomorrow morning.

I am not sure what they do on one of those occasions where it warms up overnight rather than cooling down.
But that makes sense because when you check a weather forecast you're interested in the predicted temperatures for the future, not what it recently has been or is now.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: JonBuoy on 22 April, 2021, 09:59:45 am
This reminds me of something I saw in a Victorian travel guide type thingy (not to a particular place), where there was a section on 'When the day begin in different parts of the word?' The possibilities included midnight, midday, sunrise, sunset and a couple of others I can't remember right now. All pretty obvious really though and just as relevant today. 'When you wake up' would be my suggestion.

The Met Office website has an offset for their 'Maximum daytime temperature' and 'Minimum nighttime temperature' headline figures.  The figures for here for today are 14 degrees max and 2 degrees min.  The maximum is fair enough but it is currently zero and has been for some time - the minimum quoted is actually for 0600 tomorrow morning.

I am not sure what they do on one of those occasions where it warms up overnight rather than cooling down.
But that makes sense because when you check a weather forecast you're interested in the predicted temperatures for the future, not what it recently has been or is now.

When I check the forecast for Saturday to see whether there will be any ice about first thing in the morning I don't want to be shown Sunday morning's temperatures under the Saturday tab.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 22 April, 2021, 10:19:00 am
Just looked at the Met office website to see how they display it. I see a minimum of 4 degrees under "Today" which they're actually forecasting for 05:00 tomorrow. Current temp here is 7 degrees (they say, it feels warmer to me). So yes it's misleading, particularly in your situation where you're checking early in the morning and this morning is colder than tomorrow morning, but I guess they've decided this best reflects most people's usage patterns. Perhaps their "today" means "a rolling 24 hours starting now"? It's possible to think of all sorts of situations where any definition of "today" could go wrong – whatever their "today" is, it might help if they explained it somewhere!
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Polar Bear on 22 April, 2021, 10:28:04 am
Rated to the am / pm confusion,  when a legal document such as home or car insurance states that the policy commences at midnight on nth of month, is that actually possible? 

I always assume it means at the start of the 24 hours of that day but it isn't really cast iron clear in it's meaning to me and it's rarely clarified in any meanings and definitions section of the document.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: rower40 on 22 April, 2021, 10:39:56 am
A few thoughts about time (further drift from why we need to tell Google our date-of-birth!)

Trains (in Network-Rail land anyway) are never timetabled to arrive or depart at 00:00 hrs, due to the potential confusion as to which day it applies to.  If the running time between A and B is such that the arrival at B would be on the dot of midnight, then an extra minute is added so that it arrives at 00:01.  (So we don't have a midnight train to Georgia, or anywhere else for that matter.)

My first ever trip on a Voyager was a FridayNight-SaturdayMorning service from Mordor Central to the Southwest.  The onboard software for the Passenger Information Display couldn't cope with midnight, so it showed the Cheltenham arrival time as 25:30, Bristol Parkway at 26:20 and similar all the way to Plymouth.

The software suite I mostly work with stores times in 5-second units since midnight, so that they fit in a 16-bit word.  (Memory was expensive when this was written in the 1980s.)  Times between midnight and 3am are treated as belonging to the previous day, so we have a concept of a "27-hour clock".  At 3am, any remaining trains in the system have 24-hours-worth of time taken off all their timing points, so as to jump to the current day.   There are far fewer trains active at 3am than at midnight.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: phantasmagoriana on 22 April, 2021, 11:07:13 am
Rated to the am / pm confusion,  when a legal document such as home or car insurance states that the policy commences at midnight on nth of month, is that actually possible? 

I always assume it means at the start of the 24 hours of that day but it isn't really cast iron clear in it's meaning to me and it's rarely clarified in any meanings and definitions section of the document.

I'm never quite sure on this, either. At work I set up lots of online assessments for students, and always go for 11.59pm as the deadline (rather than midnight) to avoid any confusion!
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Kim on 22 April, 2021, 12:13:03 pm
Rated to the am / pm confusion,  when a legal document such as home or car insurance states that the policy commences at midnight on nth of month, is that actually possible? 

I always assume it means at the start of the 24 hours of that day but it isn't really cast iron clear in it's meaning to me and it's rarely clarified in any meanings and definitions section of the document.

I'm never quite sure on this, either. At work I set up lots of online assessments for students, and always go for 11.59pm as the deadline (rather than midnight) to avoid any confusion!

To me midnight is unambiguously the start of the new day, but some people have other ideas, so it's generally best to avoid it.

It's rounding that breaks my BRANES.  For some reason we round upwards away from zero.  (So your stopwatch goes -3, -2, -1, 0 ,1, 2, 3 rather than -2, -1, -0, 0, 1, 2, 3.  Fine.) 

But doesn't that mean a four-digit clock is supposed to flip its least significant digit at the 30seconds-past-the-minute point, rather than on the minute?  Most of them don't.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 22 April, 2021, 12:20:06 pm
Contextual, I'd say. If I was given a deadline of midnight on the 5th, then at 23:59 on the 5th I'd be panicking and at 00:01 on the 6th I'd either be relaxed or given up. (Nah, I'm pretty good at meeting deadlines!) But if an insurance policy started at midnight on the 5th and my house burnt down at 00:01 on the 6th, well I'd have to hope but I'm not sure.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: yorkie on 22 April, 2021, 03:58:55 pm
A few thoughts about time (further drift from why we need to tell Google our date-of-birth!)

Trains (in Network-Rail land anyway) are never timetabled to arrive or depart at 00:00 hrs, due to the potential confusion as to which day it applies to.  If the running time between A and B is such that the arrival at B would be on the dot of midnight, then an extra minute is added so that it arrives at 00:01.  (So we don't have a midnight train to Georgia, or anywhere else for that matter.)


The old British Rail Great Britain Passenger Timetable used to show midnight arrivals as 23:59 and departures as 00:01, the current National Rail one could well be somewhat different.


Back in the day, Thomas Cook's European timetable used to show a midnight arrival as 24:00 and a midnight departure as 00:00, just to muddy the water somewhat.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: drossall on 22 April, 2021, 09:55:26 pm
I moved between England & Scotland and back, eventually registering with a GP after each move. My medical records failed to materialise, which I couldn't quite understand.

Eventually it transpired that my DoB of ** Jun **** had been misread as ** Jan ****.
This is not as bad as the story that did the rounds recently of someone who was called in to the GP as an emergency obesity case. After some investigation, it emerged that the patient's height had been measured in metres, but recorded in centimetres, or some-such, resulting in a BMI in the 28,000 region.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: hellymedic on 22 April, 2021, 10:06:39 pm
It is MUCH more believable that I have a birthdate 5 months ahead of my arrival.

A BMI of umpteen thousand is obvious rubbish. No way could anybody guess an adult's month of birth correctly.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 23 April, 2021, 08:17:42 am
Sounds like a classic case of doctor's handwriting!
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: citoyen on 23 April, 2021, 09:39:18 am
This is not as bad as the story that did the rounds recently of someone who was called in to the GP as an emergency obesity case. After some investigation, it emerged that the patient's height had been measured in metres, but recorded in centimetres, or some-such, resulting in a BMI in the 28,000 region.

It wasn't the obesity per se that they called him in for - the anomaly only came to light because he was invited in for a vaccine, which he queried due to being young, fit and healthy, and not a key worker.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: drossall on 23 April, 2021, 05:57:51 pm
That was it. Thanks.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Morat on 23 April, 2021, 07:57:10 pm
I wouldn't mind so much, but they also often can't get 12 am/pm correct.
Nobody can. Neither of them can be correct. As Wikipedia says:
Quote
It is not always clear what times "12:00 a.m." and "12:00 p.m." denote. From the Latin words meridies (midday), ante (before) and post (after), the term ante meridiem (a.m.) means before midday and post meridiem (p.m.) means after midday. Since "noon" (midday, meridies (m.)) is neither before nor after itself, the terms a.m. and p.m. do not apply.[2] Although "12 m." was suggested as a way to indicate noon, this is seldom done[20] and also does not resolve the question of how to indicate midnight.

The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language states "By convention, 12 AM denotes midnight and 12 PM denotes noon. Because of the potential for confusion, it is advisable to use 12 noon and 12 midnight."[24]

E. G. Richards in his book Mapping Time provided a diagram in which 12 a.m. means noon and 12 p.m. means midnight.[25]

The style manual of the United States Government Printing Office used 12 a.m. for noon and 12 p.m. for midnight until its 2008 edition, when it reversed these designations[17][18] and then retained that change in its 2016 revision.[26]

Many U.S. style guides, and NIST's "Frequently asked questions (FAQ)" web page,[2] recommend that it is clearest if one refers to "noon" or "12:00 noon" and "midnight" or "12:00 midnight" (rather than to "12:00 p.m." and "12:00 a.m."). The NIST website states that "12 a.m. and 12 p.m. are ambiguous and should not be used."

The Associated Press Stylebook specifies that midnight "is part of the day that is ending, not the one that is beginning."[23]

The Canadian Press Stylebook[21] says, "write noon or midnight, not 12 noon or 12 midnight." Phrases such as "12 a.m." and "12 p.m." are not mentioned at all. Britain's National Physical Laboratory "FAQ-Time" web page[22] states "In cases where the context cannot be relied upon to place a particular event, the pair of days straddling midnight can be quoted"; also "the terms 12 a.m. and 12 p.m. should be avoided."

Likewise, some U.S. style guides recommend either clarifying "midnight" with other context clues, such as specifying the two dates between which it falls, or not referring to the term at all. For an example of the latter method, "midnight" is replaced with "11:59 p.m." for the end of a day or "12:01 a.m." for the start of a day. That has become common in the United States in legal contracts and for airplane, bus, or train schedules, though some schedules use other conventions. Occasionally, when trains run at regular intervals, the pattern may be broken at midnight by displacing the midnight departure one or more minutes, such as to 11:59 p.m. or 12:01 a.m.[27]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/12-hour_clock#:~:text=The%20American%20Heritage%20Dictionary%20of,12%20noon%20and%2012%20midnight."

Similarly, is midnight 00:00 or 24:00? It's a different case, because both are correct rather than neither, and more importantly because whichever you use, it's not confusing (except to Americans).

For the UK forces, there is no midnight. You can plan H hour for 2359 or 0001 but never 0000 because it has been deemed non-existant.
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: hellymedic on 23 April, 2021, 11:06:05 pm
Sounds like a classic case of doctor's handwriting!

I think my writing was pretty clear; their READING...

I would say that, wouldn't I?

Srsly, before I became unable to hold a pen, my writing was legible. Sheila never complained about my Arrivée contributions...

('Retrace to Mencap' resulted in a hand-written, detailed route sheet I could read from the bars...)
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 24 April, 2021, 08:56:21 am
Yes, you would say that! Actually I thought the date was on the file or whatever written by your ex-GP, not on something written by you!
Title: Re: Google account birthday request
Post by: hellymedic on 24 April, 2021, 12:52:02 pm
My OLD NHS number related to my Number in the Birth Register. I think DoB anomalies might have been easier to spot as births in London N16 at the time were PKO* NNN , where N were sequential numerals...
Charles Docking (the Registrar) would be turning in his grave...