Yet Another Cycling Forum

General Category => Freewheeling => Topic started by: Blodwyn Pig on 01 April, 2021, 07:51:43 pm

Title: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Blodwyn Pig on 01 April, 2021, 07:51:43 pm
Well 12 of us met up today  for a 73km from Tonbridge, to Edenbridge, to Forest Row, To Tunbridge  Wells, back to Tonbridge. I know it was April 1st, and joking aside, and all Covid matters aside, I was genuinely shocked at the level of competence of some individuals, I mean riding 3 a breast , up a hill, on a narrow lane, with cars trying to pass, and general, 'wandering all over the road' type thing.  I don't know if its.....
a) because I've ridden on my own too long, and am intolerant
b) because these individuals haven't ridden in a group for a long time, and have forgotten
c) a+b
d) they just don't care.

If I said I was one of the youngest, you might get where I'm coming from.  Made car drivers raise their hands in despair, and made i cringe.

Any one else been out with a group and had a shock?
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: guidon on 01 April, 2021, 08:35:04 pm
Same over here in la Belle France after lockdown last year (we're right in it again after saturday....) the amount of "racers" crashing out in races was very shocking and road manners ..... well....how some chose to argue with 44 tonne lorries ???
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: freeflow on 02 April, 2021, 09:42:56 am
My understanding is that we are limited to groups if six rather than solo or pairs.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Paul H on 02 April, 2021, 10:32:07 am
My understanding is that we are limited to groups if six rather than solo or pairs.
Depends who the "we" is.
In England, informal groups are limited to six, club rides, that meet the criteria, can run rides  for groups up to fifteen.
https://www.britishcycling.org.uk/about/article/20200512-about-bc-news-British-Cycling-Updated-Coronavirus-Guidance-0
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 02 April, 2021, 10:34:54 am
My club is asking people to social distance at the start and then set off in groups of six. Also noting down groups for track&trace
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: L CC on 02 April, 2021, 10:50:04 am
Ours is asking us to pre-register.

Awful group riding has become a feature of almost every event I've done since about 2012. Can I blame the Olympic effect? There's an assumption that because you (one/I) can ride a bike you can ride in a group. No one thinks they have anything to learn, yet the advantage of being a champion wheel sucker is much greater than that of riding with tri-bars. I guess you can't order those skills off the internet and so people don't bother with them.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 02 April, 2021, 11:01:12 am
In my club it seems to be a feature of the mid-ability groups. I ride in all the speed groups depending on what I want out of the ride. The A group is well-drilled, people on the front do their job, nobody brakes suddenly, undertakes or does anything dangerous, the slowest group just pootles about nicely, but the intermediate group, oh my god. They are all nice people, but it's a stressful group to ride with. I see supertucks on the slightest decline, imaginary-tribars elbows on tops riding, crossed wheels., four abreast round corners, nobody keeping an eye out for cars approaching behind.  It's a bit of a nightmare and the only safe place to be is on the front. I do get the impression that they are mimicking what they see from pro racing.

Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 02 April, 2021, 11:04:44 am
I noticed a while ago that HK's and my group riding skills have deteriorated somewhat over the past year. I have been working on being smoother and more predictable over the past few weeks but no doubt I will surprise my companions a couple of times when we can ride in groups again, despite my best efforts. Hopefully others will make the same efforts and problems will be limited to surprises, rather than scabs.

I am self-assured enough to tell people to ride straight and don't jam on the brakes unexpectedly as required (and generally self-aware enough to accept it from others and apologise) but some folk aren't that direct and quite a few think that being told to ride better is a direct assault upon their manhood (term deliberately chosen).
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: L CC on 02 April, 2021, 11:08:34 am
I've spent so much time on Zwift I can't descend for toffee and brake for the slightest corner.
Thank goodness I have faith in my tandem pilots.  ;D
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: De Sisti on 02 April, 2021, 11:48:18 am

,, a few think that being told to ride better is a direct assault upon their manhood (term deliberately chosen).
A few years ago, whilst leading the 16mph group to Farm Park Cafe, one bloke sprinted for the cafe with head down. He came past a rider and straight into my right side, sending me to the ground. He, on the other hand, stayed upright. I sustained a bruised side, hip and torn shorts. Guess what? He didn't even apologise.

That 16 mph group (now expanded into two, sometimes three) has blokes who'll turn up, obviously riding fit, but no appreciation of group etiquette. For various reasons I eventually
moved down a group (to the 14s, now called the Social Group). The riders in this group are generally like myself with years of riding experience, or new to cycling and are eager to learn.

I've been asked to lead this group and even devise my own routes (rather than relying on the
ones on the club spreadsheet). I will do my best to uphold good road skills in the group.



Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 02 April, 2021, 11:55:06 am
I'm crap at group riding but it's nothing to do with lockdown. It's not so much etiquette (though of course there's the perennial "who goes in front when singling out" debate) but I just don't trust my reactions enough to ride in close formation. Or perhaps I should say I know they're not fast enough to allow it.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 02 April, 2021, 11:56:53 am

,, a few think that being told to ride better is a direct assault upon their manhood (term deliberately chosen).
A few years ago, whilst leading the 16mph group to Farm Park Cafe, one bloke sprinted for the cafe with head down. He came past a rider and straight into my right side, sending me to the ground. He, on the other hand, stayed upright. I sustained a bruised side, hip and torn shorts. Guess what? He didn't even apologise.
It sounds like it's not just group riding etiquette he was lacking, but basic decency.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Kim on 02 April, 2021, 12:27:09 pm
I'm crap at group riding but it's nothing to do with lockdown. It's not so much etiquette (though of course there's the perennial "who goes in front when singling out" debate) but I just don't trust my reactions enough to ride in close formation. Or perhaps I should say I know they're not fast enough to allow it.

Pretty much this, especially when I'm riding a recumbent around solo uprights, where the problem is compounded by different dynamics that you can't expect the other riders to appreciate.

I wonder how much of this problem is down to people who enjoy, and even become quite good at, cycling but are put off by traditional cycling clubs?  I'm far too slow for a "16mph group", or even a "14mph group" (assuming standard 1% average rolling hills), so there don't seem to be many opportunities for learning group riding etiquette, beyond the common-sense hold your line, point out hazards and only pass on the right stuff of social rides.

What close-formation riding skills I have developed have been from things like hill climbing at wow-factor-1, trying to stay within audio range of barakta and indeed silly bike racing.  That's mostly a case of anticipation and trying to be predictable, rather than any formal etiquette, though.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 02 April, 2021, 12:44:36 pm
the common-sense hold your line, point out hazards and only pass on the right stuff of social rides.
I think it's only common sense once you've experienced it a bit. And, again, there's always a certain room for disagreement on what should and shouldn't be called. Example: Descending the north side of Alfred's Tower in Wiltshire with a friend. This is a steep, narrow, very badly surfaced lane. I was just in front and calling out "Hole! Hole! Stick! Hole! Stone! Hole! Hole! Hole!" while trying to avoid said hazards and indicate which side they were without swerving in front of him. When we got to the bottom, he said "You didn't call that drain" to which I replied "Because it went the whole width of the road and there was no way to avoid it." There probably isn't any point calling a hazard you can't avoid. But in fact he has a point; as second, your view is slightly limited and knowing what is there, even if you can't avoid it, helps you prepare.

But the one that annoys me is when you're riding on a main road or in town and someone insists on calling out every approaching car.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Kim on 02 April, 2021, 12:52:42 pm
There probably isn't any point calling a hazard you can't avoid. But in fact he has a point; as second, your view is slightly limited and knowing what is there, even if you can't avoid it, helps you prepare.

Every stoker knows this, and the stoker is always right.


Quote
But the one that annoys me is when you're riding on a main road or in town and someone insists on calling out every approaching car.

I recall a Cyclebirminghm ride a few years ago that featured one of those.  We were hacking our way through the badlands of Solihull and he was yelling about every approaching car with life-or-death urgency.  Yes, we know.  We're already singled-out.  We're riding through I-can't-believe-it's-not-Birmingham.  Of course there's a CAR!
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 02 April, 2021, 01:02:19 pm
Once the density of defects gets too great, I just call ‘crap all over’ and leave the other rider to sort out the details since I will have got too occupied doing just that.

Incessant car callers sometimes respond appropriately to a sarcastic “Tell me something I don’t know!” Otherwise, I just ride somewhere quieter.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Kim on 02 April, 2021, 01:07:38 pm
Once the density of defects gets too great, I just call ‘crap all over’ and leave the other rider to sort out the details since I will have got too occupied doing just that.

There's a point[1] where becomes easier to point out the patches of good tarmac.


[1] Somewhere around level 8 of Potholeman 3000
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Lightning Phil on 02 April, 2021, 01:14:23 pm
Our CTC group riding skills leave something to be desired.  Particularly the ride leader who suddenly stops or makes a turn without announcing it in advance. The smaller groups of six, at the moment, are far better.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 02 April, 2021, 01:21:05 pm
Once the density of defects gets too great, I just call ‘crap all over’ and leave the other rider to sort out the details since I will have got too occupied doing just that.

Incessant car callers sometimes respond appropriately to a sarcastic “Tell me something I don’t know!” Otherwise, I just ride somewhere quieter.
Both sensible.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 02 April, 2021, 01:38:50 pm
I have stopped riding with the intermediate group not only because it is stressful and I prefer to chill, but also because it puts me in another position that I don't want to be in. I don't want to be the guy who barks instructions or gives advice...but there have been a few occasions where with this group we have narrowly avoided serious collisions with vehicles because of riding skills just not being there.

The last time this happened was in a large group on a main road, approaching a right turn. I was somewhere near the front. We were signalling well ahead of the turn, and I noticed people moving over the white line. An impatient driver appeared behind and started overtaking the group at speed (est 50mph), by which time one person had moved right over without checking behind. I screamed "watch out" and he shifted over to the left but the car was inches away and would have hit him full on. It was nearest miss I have ever seen.

After the incident I said to the few who had moved without looking "You really should look before moving right". They accepted it, but as I said I don't want to be that guy so solution is to not ride with them.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: L CC on 02 April, 2021, 02:57:14 pm
I wonder how much of this problem is down to people who enjoy, and even become quite good at, cycling but are put off by traditional cycling clubs?  I'm far too slow for a "16mph group", or even a "14mph group" (assuming standard 1% average rolling hills), so there don't seem to be many opportunities for learning group riding etiquette, beyond the common-sense hold your line, point out hazards and only pass on the right stuff of social rides.
16mph and 14mph are MUCH MUCH easier in a group than alone. 30% less effort easier (https://cyclingtips.com/2017/10/much-benefit-really-get-drafting/). It is worth learning group riding skills to take advantage of this.
Common sense is not as common as you'd think from its name.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: TimC on 02 April, 2021, 03:18:52 pm
Even though I'm a club committee member, I won't do group rides for all the reasons given above. I'm not interested in pretending to be a competitive rider, and I get thoroughly fed up with all the shouting. I'm very happy that some enjoy it, and I do try to get people to think about coming up with a consistent, simple and repeatable set of group riding rules, but I don't think I've succeeded.

I suspect this weekend will see some very dodgy group rides. I'm staying on Zwift.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 02 April, 2021, 03:25:57 pm
As I hinted it seems to be the intermediates that pretend to be competitive in my club. The slowest group are great for a social ride, bumbling about. People tend to move around to chat with everyone else, almost like a load of small groups. The fastest group is good because everyone is super disciplined but also relaxed because of it. There are times when nobody is bothering, but equally it can turn into a really well oiled, confident chaingang which is quite easy to be a part of especially if you want some fast miles and a bit of a workout. I'd never maintain that intensity on my own.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: TimC on 02 April, 2021, 03:34:50 pm
It's probably fair to say that what I really mean is I'm nowhere near fast enough to do group rides these days. The days of keeping up with a 35-38kph group are long gone!
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 02 April, 2021, 03:40:13 pm
Our slowest group is 12-14 mph. Fastest is usually 20+mph, so for me it is all or nothing. Oddly though, I usually feel more tired after the slow rides than the fast ones.

I haven't ridden with them for ages, so I might be being presumptuous about riding in the fast group.  :facepalm:
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 02 April, 2021, 03:40:48 pm
I wonder how much of this problem is down to people who enjoy, and even become quite good at, cycling but are put off by traditional cycling clubs?  I'm far too slow for a "16mph group", or even a "14mph group" (assuming standard 1% average rolling hills), so there don't seem to be many opportunities for learning group riding etiquette, beyond the common-sense hold your line, point out hazards and only pass on the right stuff of social rides.
16mph and 14mph are MUCH MUCH easier in a group than alone. 30% less effort easier (https://cyclingtips.com/2017/10/much-benefit-really-get-drafting/). It is worth learning group riding skills to take advantage of this.
Common sense is not as common as you'd think from its name.
That's true even if you're riding as a looser group, as opposed to an in-formation chaingang. Perhaps not 30% but certainly an appreciable amount.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: citoyen on 02 April, 2021, 03:42:02 pm
Back when I used to ride with the club regularly, there was one particular pillock who was absolutely the worst kind of group rider - always turned up in full Sky kit, which was reason enough to hate him anyway, but he would sit doggedly at the back of the group, never doing his turn, until we got to any hill when he would put the hammer down and sprint off the front to get his precious fictional KOM points.

That aside, the groups on club rides were mostly pretty good - largely because we had some old boys who enforced discipline. And they were also good at teaching newbies. I think one of them must have had a word with FKW boy because he abruptly stopped turning up.

The club seems to have fragmented a bit lately though - even pre-pandemic. For the Sunday ride, we would all meet up in one big bunch and set off together before the different groups split off (on my very first ride with the club, I made the mistake of being near the front when the fast group split off and got swept along with them... managed to hold on for a couple of miles but then blew up spectacularly). In the last few years (pre-pandemic), it seems to be lots of different small groups meeting up at different times, and most of the focus is on the racing team, time trials and Go Ride. Don't know what is going to happen now that group riding is allowed again.

There's another local club that I used to ride with years ago until it kind of fizzled out, but then it seemed to have a bit of a revival and a big influx of new members. They're more of a sociable group than pretend racers. I'm tempted to go back to them, except their group rides are now on Saturdays so clash with parkrun. No idea what the riding standard is like but the ones I used to ride with were pretty good - a couple of them had been racers to a pretty high standard back in the 60s/70s (one raced at national level for the RAF team).
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: citoyen on 02 April, 2021, 03:45:08 pm
16mph and 14mph are MUCH MUCH easier in a group than alone.

Absolutely.

Group riding is probably also the best way to get faster - when I started riding regularly with the club, the 16mph group was a bit beyond my comfort zone, but riding with them regularly meant I was soon a lot more comfortable at that pace.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Ribena75 on 02 April, 2021, 05:24:19 pm
But the one that annoys me is when you're riding on a main road or in town and someone insists on calling out every approaching car.

I sometimes go with a group that are like this. Constant hand signals for parked cars, lots of shouting. "Car back!"

Guys... we're in Bromley.

I've been cycling by myself though since last lockdown, and tbh I find it much less stressful.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 02 April, 2021, 05:28:40 pm
Out here in the wolds it's often the unbelievable road surfaces that are the danger. Gloucestershire must have the shittest roads in the UK. At one point for several years even driving down the A46 in a car involved slaloming round holes that would break your car instantly.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Kim on 02 April, 2021, 05:39:03 pm
I wonder how much of this problem is down to people who enjoy, and even become quite good at, cycling but are put off by traditional cycling clubs?  I'm far too slow for a "16mph group", or even a "14mph group" (assuming standard 1% average rolling hills), so there don't seem to be many opportunities for learning group riding etiquette, beyond the common-sense hold your line, point out hazards and only pass on the right stuff of social rides.
16mph and 14mph are MUCH MUCH easier in a group than alone. 30% less effort easier (https://cyclingtips.com/2017/10/much-benefit-really-get-drafting/). It is worth learning group riding skills to take advantage of this.

Having wheel-sucked (and occasionally gravitationally slingshotted) my way to the middle of the BHPC's fast group, I'm acutely aware of this.  But I still don't really have a good idea for how the average speed of a group compares to riding solo in real-world conditions.

Doing it amongst broadly similar machines on the track is one thing, on the road where Potholeman fears to tread is quite another.


Quote
Common sense is not as common as you'd think from its name.

So true.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 02 April, 2021, 06:05:22 pm
Out here in the wolds it's often the unbelievable road surfaces that are the danger. Gloucestershire must have the shittest roads in the UK. At one point for several years even driving down the A46 in a car involved slaloming round holes that would break your car instantly.
They've held the title for four decades at least. Back in the 1980s they once chip-and-sealed the M5.  ::-)
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: giropaul on 02 April, 2021, 06:13:11 pm
I think it’s two factors at play, in particular.
- the number of “ new” for want of a better term, is a high percentage of many rides. Going back, there would just be one or two newer riders, who would learn from the rest. At the same time, the newer people may have been reading the magazines, watching GCN etc. It’s also the case that many aren’t the fresh faced youngsters we were , and may take les well to advice.
- the March of data! Many are obsessed with data, average speed, segments etc etc. That doesn’t mix well in a group. I recall a club ride a while back, cold and damp, and most of the more experienced were on winter bikes with guards.
One chap, close to me, on a new looking £8,000 odd bike with full carbon everything, was clearly agitated. I asked if he was ok - no he wasn’t apparently, the ride was 2mph slower than last time and his Strava was going to look bad.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Lightning Phil on 02 April, 2021, 06:19:23 pm
I’m definitely in for the social when group riding. Especially as 90% of my riding is recumbent these days.  Can’t wait for when the pub or café stop returns on a ride. Fastest group socials are around 15 mph, slowest around 12 mph.  But that can disguise how uphills, flat, and downhills are tackled. Some ride leaders are better at pacing than others.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Blodwyn Pig on 02 April, 2021, 06:25:35 pm
I too soon get fed up with the 'noise'. My local CTC group has more than its fair share of 'sheep'.  Riding along a country lane, in the dark, and an oncoming car  (in the distance) is greeted with a call, from the most observant of the flock, to call out  ''oil down!!!!!'', followed by 3 or more members of the flock, in rapid succession, (ALWAYS the same 3) .....''oil down!..oil down!! oil down!!!, who are often not even looking where the are going anyway. Dazzled by headlights, my normal vocal reaction is ...'' No shit, Sherlock'' Really pisses me off!            STFU!!!!!!!!!!!!!! dimwits!


I may be sad, but I have a MANTRA......''words are precious, use them wisely'
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Lightning Phil on 02 April, 2021, 06:29:25 pm
Indeed, meanwhile they forget to call out the large pothole you ride straight into.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: MattH on 02 April, 2021, 06:54:16 pm
It's been ages since I've done a proper ride in a group. I used to ride in either the fast group (normally four or five - a good number - and skilled riders) or the slow group as I'd be out with one of my kids too. I stopped riding with the club (and ultimately left) when they made plastic headgear mandatory. There had been an influx of racer wanabees, which changed the whole feel of the club.

I'm quite worried about BC racing starting up again; there's going to be a lot of riders who are Zwift fit and powerful, but lost the peloton riding skills. I suspect the medics may see a bit of action on the first few events.

Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: slugbait on 02 April, 2021, 07:51:38 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace? My local club has a 28, 32 and 36 km/h groups (roughly 17, 20 and 22mph). The 28 and 32 groups are the social ones and no one is left behind. The 36 group doesn't wait (Flat tyre or too fast? Tough luck).
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 02 April, 2021, 07:54:14 pm
Standard lumpiness in most of the UK is 1000m climbing/ 100km. That qualifies as very hilly in the Netherlands. A group’s comfortable average speed reflects both the riders and the conditions.

When I’ve ridden brevets in the Netherlands, my pace has generally been somewhat higher than my UK average.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: slugbait on 02 April, 2021, 08:13:19 pm
Thanks, I did not consider hills. I need to get some cycling done outside of the Netherlands soon, hopefully...
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 02 April, 2021, 08:15:06 pm
What do mean there are no hills in the Netherlands???  There are all those little bridges over the canals!
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: The Family Cyclist on 02 April, 2021, 08:22:48 pm
I'm quite worried about BC racing starting up again; there's going to be a lot of riders who are Zwift fit and powerful, but lost the peloton riding skills. I suspect the medics may see a bit of action on the first few events.

There was an article last year but guess was talking about yesr before in Ireland saying the amount of crashes in local racing has gone mad as you say everyone is basically doing weights on their legs so putting out huge power with no road sense. A friend of mine who I ride with is worried as the people from work who have all bought peleton or similar bikes want to go for a ride and they're all in theory much much faster then him but no idea if they can actually transfer to the road where you have to pay attention

Group wise I ride with around 6 people normally of mixed abilities but largely and this probably applies when I'm with bigger groups roll in pairs or threea not as a big mass

I did once go out with a bunch who a more regular cycling buddy was going with. Advertised as around 30 to 35 miles at around 16mph. Ended up being over 40 at nearer 20 but managed to hang on, i didn't contribute anything on the front as was hanging on the back the whole time. I got a puncture about 5 miles from home and happy to let them go. The guy i sometimes rode with was happy to wait with me as was pretty knackered as well.

Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: TimC on 02 April, 2021, 08:32:38 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace? My local club has a 28, 32 and 36 km/h groups (roughly 17, 20 and 22mph). The 28 and 32 groups are the social ones and no one is left behind. The 36 group doesn't wait (Flat tyre or too fast? Tough luck).

We're not overburdened with hills where I live (south Suffolk), though what there are are tend to be vicious little things. My current club has a 32kph group, whose ranks I've never bothered, and a 26kph/16mph group who only pay lip service to the intended speed. It's a no-drop group, so they do wait every so often when they realise there's only two riders left, but it does get a bit over-enthusiastic at times. But we don't have any racers. My previous club had similar groups to yours, and the 36-38 group waits for no-one. Indeed, if possible they'll get the speeds up as fast as they can! There was a time when I'd occasionally play with them, but not now. I can still average 28 or so on my own so I could probably hang with the evens crowd on the flat, but I am most definitely gravitationally challenged on anything remotely uphill. Solo works best!
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: peterc on 02 April, 2021, 11:44:13 pm
Thanks, I did not consider hills.

Thats okay, I don't think we fully understand headwinds, I mean I know they exist, but not how they could be so bad that you might need aerobars on an omafiets.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: TimC on 03 April, 2021, 02:44:37 pm
Solo'd my way to a local outdoor cycling caff this morning for a latte and a bacon butty. A club from a big town nearish-by arrived in force - about 40-50 peeps in groups varying from 4 to 20 over about 10 minutes, suggesting they'd all left together (or coordinated their arrival extremely efficiently). No attempt to keep to the mandated 15, and even less to keep to legal groups of 6 once off the bike. The weather was very cold and windy. The forecast for tomorrow is a tad more ride-friendly; if you want to see the law being broken I suspect this'll be the day to do it!
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Lightning Phil on 03 April, 2021, 03:40:28 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace? My local club has a 28, 32 and 36 km/h groups (roughly 17, 20 and 22mph). The 28 and 32 groups are the social ones and no one is left behind. The 36 group doesn't wait (Flat tyre or too fast? Tough luck).

Blimey you must get round Dutch audax 200s in around 6 hours.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: slugbait on 03 April, 2021, 04:28:17 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace? My local club has a 28, 32 and 36 km/h groups (roughly 17, 20 and 22mph). The 28 and 32 groups are the social ones and no one is left behind. The 36 group doesn't wait (Flat tyre or too fast? Tough luck).

Blimey you must get round Dutch audax 200s in around 6 hours.

Alas, over 200km I don't go much faster 28km/h. Add a coffee stop and it takes me roughly 8 hours.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: De Sisti on 03 April, 2021, 04:48:49 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace?
So what!?
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: rogerzilla on 03 April, 2021, 08:40:50 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace? My local club has a 28, 32 and 36 km/h groups (roughly 17, 20 and 22mph). The 28 and 32 groups are the social ones and no one is left behind. The 36 group doesn't wait (Flat tyre or too fast? Tough luck).
Is that a cruising speed or an average?  We'd normally do 18-19mph on the flat, but the average, including junctions and hills, usually comes out at about 15.5mph.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Wowbagger on 03 April, 2021, 08:48:47 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace?
So what!?

In answer to the question quoted, no, 14mph and 16mph are not relaxed paces. 10mph is fast these days.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Socks on 03 April, 2021, 08:50:39 pm
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace?
So what!?

In answer to the question quoted, no, 14mph and 16mph are not relaxed paces. 10mph is fast these days.

As someone in my family said, it's all relative
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Zed43 on 03 April, 2021, 09:33:44 pm
In answer to the question quoted, no, 14mph and 16mph are not relaxed paces. 10mph is fast these days.
I feel better now (23 kph avg over flat 210km, with some unpaved)
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: slugbait on 04 April, 2021, 08:42:00 am
I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace?
So what!?

It doesn't matter, just needed context. I fully understand that what is fast pace depends on the terrain and the rider.

I have to ask (as someone living in the Netherlands). Isn't both 14mph and 16mph a rather relaxed pace? My local club has a 28, 32 and 36 km/h groups (roughly 17, 20 and 22mph). The 28 and 32 groups are the social ones and no one is left behind. The 36 group doesn't wait (Flat tyre or too fast? Tough luck).
Is that a cruising speed or an average?  We'd normally do 18-19mph on the flat, but the average, including junctions and hills, usually comes out at about 15.5mph.

Average, but we don't have many junctions here, or even tight corners (current position 53.23N, 6.52E). And the nearest natural hill worth mentioning is 130km away.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: giropaul on 04 April, 2021, 09:03:33 am
I’d suggest that the fact that km/h are being monitored and discussed are evidence that the relaxed attitude of the traditional “ pace of slowest ride” is a thing of the past.
On the old, relaxed, rides I would often be in the company of international, successful, riders. They were content to be social, and reserve training efforts for more appropriate times. Often they might do an hour or two before the club run, or return from the cafe in a smaller group, but whilst with the club run they’d concentrate on keeping it together and at a sensible pace.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 04 April, 2021, 09:22:56 am
That certainly isn't the case for the club I ride with occasionally.  There are speed groups, 12-14mph, 15-18mph, and 18+mph.  It is a 'no drop' policy so effectively it is the pace of the slowest rider, although hills are fair game for everyone (wait at the top).  Equally, we have no internationally succesful rider, nor do most clubs, and you wouldn't expect a semi/professional/ 1sr cat  rider to use a town club ride as training (other than recovery)
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: DuncanM on 04 April, 2021, 10:07:06 am
The club I belong to has instigated a new policy when advertising rides.  The leader is expected to state the expected speed (on the flat), and the attitude (social, developmental, screamer). Only having 6 on a ride means that one person ending up in the wrong group has an impact on everyone. I don't think we have any men who are >3rd cat (they tend to move on to more racing focused teams), but there are a couple of very competitive women at the moment.
I've not actually ridden in a group on the road since early 2019 I think (though I rode some CX races in late 2019), down to injuries and ride clashes with family stuff mainly.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: fd3 on 04 April, 2021, 02:10:39 pm
The group I would ride with ... that was over a decade ago.  Only had a slow/social group.  I have been out with a small group of local cyclists, but I am not good with pace groups as I either ride fixed or laidback, which doesn’t play well with riding in groups.  Laidback is also a bit tricky on a social ride, due to head level mismatch.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 04 April, 2021, 02:11:49 pm
Oh I don't know. Perfect for receiving one of my snot rockets.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: grams on 04 April, 2021, 02:25:52 pm
My club has numeric speeds attached to its ride categories, but they're completely notional and it all depends who turns up and what mood they're in.

The only way to find out which group you belong in is to start at the bottom and work up, or to only ride with people you know.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 04 April, 2021, 02:40:10 pm
Our speeds are attached to the groups rather than the actual ride/route.  It generally works although if it isn't a hilly route things can get quite frisky. Most people are cool with that, apart from one guy who doesn't ride for ages, then turns up (fat and unfit) in a group with a set speed he can't keep up with, but his ego demands that he join. We have to wait ages for him at the top of hills, then he gets irate if the speeds on the flat exceed his capabilities. He once directed his invective at me.   Just the once, mind.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Geriatricdolan on 04 April, 2021, 04:26:02 pm
Speeds have gone up, probably a result of Zwift and more widespread aero equipment...

In miles, 10 years ago, club rides were 12-13 for the slow group, 14-16 for the medium and 17-19 for the fast. Now it's more like 14-16 for the slow, 17-19 for the medium and 20+ for the fast.

I have seen club rides averaging 23-24 mph on Strava... and not even short rides
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 04 April, 2021, 04:28:06 pm
Don't forget that Strava is moving average which is way faster than actual average. None of the waiting around on hilltops affects the averages.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Geriatricdolan on 04 April, 2021, 04:36:11 pm
Don't forget that Strava is moving average which is way faster than actual average. None of the waiting around on hilltops affects the averages.

We were measuring moving averages even before. It's not that the good old Cateye computers didn't have the auto-pause function. Nothing has changed in that respect, just people are a lot fitter, because they train like maniacs on Zwift all year round, whereas 10 years ago, some had primitive dumb trainers in the garage to use when it rained
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Lightning Phil on 04 April, 2021, 05:19:55 pm
Laidback is also a bit tricky on a social ride, due to head level mismatch.

Which is really useful when you end up next to the boring engineer. What’s that, sorry can’t hear you, I’ll just move forward in the group. 

As to speed, laid back shouldn’t be a problem unless you are on the limit of your fitness. If you’re in your comfort zone you’re unlikely to be the last one up the hill.    Besides if CTC, you may be the first one up any hill, regardless of your bike type.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 05 April, 2021, 09:23:40 am
Rides don't get much more relaxed than Bristol CTC. At times it's more like a pub stop on wheels. But a guideline speed is always stated along with distance and sometimes a note such as "hilly" or "ride will not happen if icy". Stating a guideline speed helps it stay relaxed for everyone, by allowing people to pick a suitable ride. Slow people don't get their legs torn off, faster people don't get frustrated hanging round at every junction.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: giropaul on 05 April, 2021, 01:03:52 pm
That certainly isn't the case for the club I ride with occasionally.  There are speed groups, 12-14mph, 15-18mph, and 18+mph.  It is a 'no drop' policy so effectively it is the pace of the slowest rider, although hills are fair game for everyone (wait at the top).  Equally, we have no internationally succesful rider, nor do most clubs, and you wouldn't expect a semi/professional/ 1sr cat  rider to use a town club ride as training (other than recovery)

That’s one of my points really. These days talented riders tend to move into sponsored teams, and have little to do with club life.
In the past, the presence of “ big hitters” kept things under control, but importantly inspired and advised. Club runs and club nights, we benefited from their advice and encouragement. On a club run, they always had the legs and gravitas to keep things steady.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 05 April, 2021, 01:47:09 pm
Sure, not disputing what you are saying, just underlining that with a 'no drop' policy we are at the speed of the slowest rider.

From my perspective, everyone rolling along at a steady speed isn't that fun. It might be efficient but it's not fun, hence the odd blast and then wait for anyone who wasn't up for it on that day. (most are, it transpires)  Nobody really shits their pants over it apart from that one guy I mentioned.

The club once employed a local coach to give advice on a group ride. Proper old school.  Runs a local amateur team. Highly opinionated.  He rode 3 miles with mid group and then rode up to us. We dropped him on the big hill and then waited, at the top for him, at which point he arrived and berated us in between trying not to die.

So we dropped him again and had a great ride.
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Geriatricdolan on 05 April, 2021, 02:28:39 pm
Sure, not disputing what you are saying, just underlining that with a 'no drop' policy we are at the speed of the slowest rider.

From my perspective, everyone rolling along at a steady speed isn't that fun. It might be efficient but it's not fun, hence the odd blast and then wait for anyone who wasn't up for it on that day. (most are, it transpires)  Nobody really shits their pants over it apart from that one guy I mentioned.

The club once employed a local coach to give advice on a group ride. Proper old school.  Runs a local amateur team. Highly opinionated.  He rode 3 miles with mid group and then rode up to us. We dropped him on the big hill and then waited, at the top for him, at which point he arrived and berated us in between trying not to die.

So we dropped him again and had a great ride.

I have a club membership... I went out with them once, as you say the very steady nature of the ride made it quite regimented... that level of "do" and "don't" doesn't appeal to me.
In the past clubs were smaller and rides were less structured, often deciding where to go on the day, depending on wind and weather and who was there on the day. Nowadays there is a calendar of fixed rides which is posted in January and runs until December and they are always the same routes, which are "risk assessed" so to speak.

Bit too much, really
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: grams on 05 April, 2021, 02:35:48 pm
"Race up the hills" works great as long as you do it on the known big hills and don't get people doing it on anything that resembles an incline.

(This is the big difference between "no drop" and "pace of the slowest rider". If the slowest rider is always fighting to chase back on and/or - hopefully - being waited for then you're doing the former, not the latter)
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: Hot Flatus on 06 April, 2021, 07:56:41 am
Never really happens in any group that I am in.  Larger groups tend to roll around and actual speeds go up and down with the terrain. I have noticed that a few people seem to fall off when speeds go up without any real increase in effort (because slight decline or tailwind) which is weird. Equally you get the people who sit on the front and then stop pedalling downhill...actually quite annoying.  I rarely see anybody trying to deliberately drop anyone (except on the big climbs, which is fair enough). Also there are always a few shepherds (me included) who keep an eye out and drop back and pace people back or stop the group. But, there are riders who are utterly oblivious to anyone else and smash on, never looking back at all. One of the things I really like about the club is that there isn't an annoying patriarchal figure barking orders, and there are enough experienced and strong riders to silently determine pace and do the little jobs to keep things cohesive without making a show of it.  There was a self-appointed patrician, Gerald, late 60s, who would stake out his authoratitive position by telling you at every opportunity that he used to race, as if that was somehow relevant,  but he left after he mansplained once too often to a couple of women and got his comeuppance.

The small groups of faster riders is where the real naughty fun is, and people will launch an attack, often  with a huge grin, and then get dragged back by a paceline with counter-attack. We all know each other very well and none of it is about ego. It's just pissing around having a blast. It all works quite well really. 
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: mattc on 17 May, 2021, 06:22:41 pm
Also there are always a few shepherds (me included) who keep an eye out and drop back and pace people back or stop the group. But, there are riders who are utterly oblivious to anyone else and smash on, never looking back at all. One of the things I really like about the club is that there isn't an annoying patriarchal figure barking orders, and there are enough experienced and strong riders to silently determine pace and do the little jobs to keep things cohesive without making a show of it. 
Apart from the utterly oblivious whom you mention - and I think every club has a good share of those - you are very lucky to find such a group. I don't mean they're unique, just well above average. (I've been out with a LOT of groups over the years, trust me ... ). I hope you nurture them, and they flower for many a season.

And well done you for being a shepherd - didn't think you had it in you.

(I have sometimes been forced into the "barking orders" thing by groups that are almost all oblivious, with none of the "silent-but-helpful" types. It is less fun than it sounds. )
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: mattc on 17 May, 2021, 06:24:55 pm
I don't want to be the guy who barks instructions or gives advice...
<snippage>
but as I said I don't want to be that guy so solution is to not ride with them.
Aha, I see you've been through this!
Title: Re: Group riding again, OMG!
Post by: TimC on 17 May, 2021, 10:20:54 pm
I'm a club committee member, so sometimes I have to attend group rides. I do it as rarely as possible because the variation of ability and needs in a small club's group rides is so large. We don't have enough members that we can put on fast, medium and slow rides, so our sole Sunday ride is technically 15-16mph, and 25-30 miles. However, it's become the private plaything of three or four guys (of course!) who want to do 50 miles at 18mph and race for every sign and slope en route. If slower riders turn up for that ride (which is far too early for me anyway; I think it may even be before a gentleman's breakfast time of 10am*), they are tolerated, but only just. I have many times suggested a later, slower ride, but the chief racing snakes worry that it might be more attractive than their ride so resist it at all costs in case they lose their playmates victims.

The hiatus of the last 15 months has worn down their resistance, and it seems I am about to get my way. While that does mean that I might have to get off my arse on a Sunday morning, I welcome the possibility that it might mean a ride that actually abides by its description, and is a pleasant and sociable occasion. I live in hope.

*Or so I'm told.