Coming up to renewal and Pedalcover were still £80/year more than Lloyds Bank Home Insurance for me, that's with £6k of bikes named on the policy.
Last year was even cheaper as Lloyds Bank were offering 40% off the first year (and 10% off for being a Lloyds bank customer).
No personal experience of claiming through Lloyds though, but the reviews seem fine.
The other ones from a few years ago that seemed good, and not already mentioned here, was AA Home Insurance.