Even though they get it wrong every single year, I do like PAYE. Too long doing taxes in the US, where completing your 1040s is a bureaucratic ritual. I'm not sure if it's got any better, but it was a bit of form-filling nightmare, and you have to do Federal and State taxes. Most Americans are born with an innate knowledge of completing tax forms. Paperwork in general, it's a surprisingly bureaucratic society. Resisting moral turpitude in triplicate.
That said, I used to take my big box of receipts and stuff to the tax company in town, and pay them $75 or whatever.