Yet Another Cycling Forum

Off Topic => The Pub => Topic started by: Polar Bear on 15 April, 2024, 07:24:51 am

Title: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Polar Bear on 15 April, 2024, 07:24:51 am
I'll start.

A few years back we were up near Fort William and wanted to catch the train out from Banavie to Arisaig for a day trip.  It is a "pay at seat" service once out of Fort William.

When the guard came round I presented my disabled Railcard and asked for two adult returns to Arisaig.  He looked at my Railcard and ran away.  I pursued him but he locked himself in his cabin.

We alighted at Arisaig, had a pleasant few hours walking and in the cafe then caught the return.

Same guard, same routine.  He simply didn't want to know for some reason.

So yes, we travelled free on that particular day. 
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: PaulF on 15 April, 2024, 07:32:23 am
You really should get the picture changed on your railcard ;D

Closest I’ve had is when the machine hasn’t worked and the bus driver has just waved me on. But like your experience I didn’t set out to avoid the fare so I don’t think it counts.

Is it acceptable? To me it’s akin to theft and not a victimless crime as the other passengers end up subsidising the fare dodger. I’m sure someone can concoct a scenario that justifies it but to me it’s not.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Jurek on 15 April, 2024, 08:00:51 am
I've never fare dodged, accidentally or otherwise.
It's little different to shoplifting in my view.
I have a 10 minute wait to catch a connecting train at Tottenham Hale on my way in to work.
You can spot the fare dodgers before they've done the deed from a mile off.
Anyone who's not dodging their fare will have something (ticket/oyster card/phone) in their hand as they approach the gate.
The dodgers will not. They may have both hands in their pockets. They will walk uncomfortably close to the person in front  with the intention of tailgating them as they go through the gate.
I'm at TH just before 07:00 so it is quite busy. In that 10 minute period, most days I'll see 5 or 6 people go through the gates without producing anything which gives them authority to travel. The gates are staffed by 6 or more people, but none of them ever say anything to any of the dodgers - but then again, who would? You'd not really want to get stabbed over a £6.50 train fare.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Asterix, the former Gaul. on 15 April, 2024, 08:57:40 am
When I was very young, 11 or 12, I suspect I may have dodged the fare on my bus to school.  The conductor used to come round with his machine , but if you raced up the stairs to the top deck he might miss you when he came round.  Quite often a ticket inspector joined the bus - we used to call him 'Keen Eric' - he was a nice guy really and only used to make us pay what we should have done.  However, even back then I liked a walk so I used walk as far as possible to save a penny for sweets.  A few times in nice weather I walked the whole 8 miles home and on Saturdays we were allowed to cycle the eight miles.  We even cadged lifts on electric milk floats now and then. 

Of course it is totally unacceptable except when it isn't.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Regulator on 15 April, 2024, 09:13:56 am
You really should get the picture changed on your railcard ;D

Closest I’ve had is when the machine hasn’t worked and the bus driver has just waved me on. But like your experience I didn’t set out to avoid the fare so I don’t think it counts.

Is it acceptable? To me it’s akin to theft and not a victimless crime as the other passengers end up subsidising the fare dodger. I’m sure someone can concoct a scenario that justifies it but to me it’s not.


I've had that a few times.  As with you, I don't see that as fare-dodging as I was willing to pay.

Generally, I get annoyed with fare-dodging... but I also get annoyed with the moves by rail operators to get rid of station staff - which will just increase fare-dodging.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Legs on 15 April, 2024, 09:38:11 am
25 years or so ago, my mate Dave and I would go out riding our bikes and would often catch the train back home from Liss, Liphook or Haslemere by taking advantage of the Permit To Travel machines in operation there.  Not bad for 5p a time, and I'm not sure we ever had to pay up.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permit_to_travel (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permit_to_travel)
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Regulator on 15 April, 2024, 09:44:13 am
25 years or so ago, my mate Dave and I would go out riding our bikes and would often catch the train back home from Liss, Liphook or Haslemere by taking advantage of the Permit To Travel machines in operation there.  Not bad for 5p a time, and I'm not sure we ever had to pay up.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permit_to_travel (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permit_to_travel)

I remember those being introduced.  Our station (Purfleet) was one of the first to get a PERTIS machine, as it was only manned part-time (at rush hour).
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Kim on 15 April, 2024, 10:58:23 am
Not deliberately.

Certainly there have been pay-on-board occasions where the guard hasn't turned up.

And I'm sure I've done a couple of journeys on an expired season ticket that wasn't properly scrutinised before realising.

And there was that time that I found myself within the field of rower40's Psychic Paper...
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: gibbo on 15 April, 2024, 11:00:53 am
When I was very young, 11 or 12, I suspect I may have dodged the fare on my bus to school.  The conductor used to come round with his machine , but if you raced up the stairs to the top deck he might miss you when he came round.  Quite often a ticket inspector joined the bus - we used to call him 'Keen Eric' - he was a nice guy really and only used to make us pay what we should have done.  However, even back then I liked a walk so I used walk as far as possible to save a penny for sweets.  A few times in nice weather I walked the whole 8 miles home and on Saturdays we were allowed to cycle the eight miles.  We even cadged lifts on electric milk floats now and then. 

Of course it is totally unacceptable except when it isn't.

This reminds me of what happened to me when I was around that age. My younger sister and I used to bus into school and I usually had the money so I'd pay for both of us, except on one occasion, when the system got messed up and we both jumped on the bus saying my brother's/ sister's paying. Once we alighted we realised that neither of us had paid so straight to the corner shop it was. Bonus, since neither of us used to get pocket money (was spent on bus fare  ;D)

I recall telling some mates about and they tried it too, and got away with it. However, one day the driver comes down the bus to inspect the tickets. Myself and sis had paid, so no worries, but some of the others hadn't and got busted. That was enough for me not to try it again.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 15 April, 2024, 11:02:42 am
Yes and no, respectively.

The yes refers to a few months spent in a suburb of Paris as a student. I soon realised that virtually none of the other students were buying tickets on the RER, as indeed many of the non-students, so I stopped too. They had inspectors who would come round but the trains were so crowded you had to be unlucky to get caught. I never was, but always felt guilty.

Far more recently, but still over a decade ago, I had the following conversation on a Bristol suburban train:
"One adult, one child to Stapleton Road, please."
"Is he under five?"
"Yes, he's almost seven."
"Let me try again. Is [nod] he [nod] under [nod] five?"

As you can imagine, an almost seven-year-old was outraged at being classed "under five"! We later (much later, he was 11) had a similar experience on the London Underground when I literally had no idea how to buy a child ticket; at that time (don't know about now) it was free up to 10 y.o. then a child fare till 16 (or 15 or 17 or something). Machines didn't sell such tickets, there was a window but closed, this was before tapping, but there were staff hanging around who said "He's ten, he goes free."
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: T42 on 15 April, 2024, 11:13:39 am
Once did Edinburgh-London in first class on a second-class ticket. Not exactly deliberately, but second class was crowded old carriages and first wasn't.  Never saw an inspector.


Yes and no, respectively.

The yes refers to a few months spent in a suburb of Paris as a student. I soon realised that virtually none of the other students were buying tickets on the RER, as indeed many of the non-students, so I stopped too. They had inspectors who would come round but the trains were so crowded you had to be unlucky to get caught. I never was, but always felt guilty.



I used to have a colleague who calculated the odds of being inspected on the RER to be about 1:20. She then reckoned that the monthly cost of the fine would be less than a monthly season ticket, so she stopped buying them.  She was then caught three times in one week and done as a habitual offender.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Wowbagger on 15 April, 2024, 11:23:13 am
When I used to do the FNRttC, I often travelled for very little.

My local station, Prittlewell, had a “permit to travel” dispenser rather than a ticket machine. Any coin would do, so I used to put a coin in- usually a 5p or 10p - and I would receive a small slip of sticky-backed paper with the amount I had paid displayed on it. That permitted me to travel legally. If a ticket seller were on the train, I would buy a single ticket and whatever I had put in the machine would be deducted from the full price.

More commonly, I would be on an almost deserted train arriving in Lpoo St at about 11pm on a Friday. The place was invariably full of inebriated city workers all hoping to get home without throwing up, and the train operating company’s method of dealing with this was simply to open all the barriers and let people walk on with, as Jurek mentions, few staff around to be the butt of inebriate ribaldry or worse. For me to have converted my Permit to Travel to a full ticket would have involved running the gauntlet of these crowds, encumbered by a bicycle, to find an understaffed ticket office. So I didn’t.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: John Stonebridge on 15 April, 2024, 11:27:08 am
Like most anti social behaviour its never acceptable but some will seek to justify it. 

I did it occasionally when I was a student travelling Falkirk - Edinburgh on the train.   

The introduction of automatic ticket barriers has presumably reduced the issue substantially but not entirely for train travel.  I'm sure I read somewhere that automatic barriers started being installed at big stations (London Waterloo 1st iirc?) and the roll out continued until it stopped paying for itself.  It ended up that even in relatively small stations the cost of implementation was justified such was the extent of fare dodging.     

My rail travel these days tends to be Haymarket - Falkirk High and the latter doesn't have barriers which always surprises me given that its on the Edin - Glasgow express and is fairly sizeable.  On my last visit there was a group of Scotrail staff doing manual checks - first time in ages I can remember such a thing. 

.   
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: John Stonebridge on 15 April, 2024, 11:29:50 am
Yes and no, respectively.

The yes refers to a few months spent in a suburb of Paris as a student. I soon realised that virtually none of the other students were buying tickets on the RER, as indeed many of the non-students, so I stopped too. They had inspectors who would come round but the trains were so crowded you had to be unlucky to get caught. I never was, but always felt guilty.

Far more recently, but still over a decade ago, I had the following conversation on a Bristol suburban train:
"One adult, one child to Stapleton Road, please."
"Is he under five?"
"Yes, he's almost seven."
"Let me try again. Is [nod] he [nod] under [nod] five?"

As you can imagine, an almost seven-year-old was outraged at being classed "under five"! We later (much later, he was 11) had a similar experience on the London Underground when I literally had no idea how to buy a child ticket; at that time (don't know about now) it was free up to 10 y.o. then a child fare till 16 (or 15 or 17 or something). Machines didn't sell such tickets, there was a window but closed, this was before tapping, but there were staff hanging around who said "He's ten, he goes free."

That reminds me of being told to "sit wee" by my mum when I was maybe 6 or 7.    :D
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: mcshroom on 15 April, 2024, 12:51:46 pm
As a student I found that standing on the front of the Transpennine Express train from Sheffield Midland to Meadowhall station meant that usually you arrived and got off the train before the guard could get to you to sell you a ticket. Most of the time I had a season ticket but I will admit I dodged a few fares that way. In my head I justified it by having the money there if they asked for it but it wasn't acceptable though.

I also caught a GWR train on tickets for the wrong day once. In that case it was the mistake of our company travel team. The guard was very relaxed about it but could have charged us a fortune for walk up fares if he'd wanted to.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Polar Bear on 15 April, 2024, 01:10:26 pm
I do know an accountant who was sacked for fare dodging. 

It hurt their career significantly.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: lissotriton on 15 April, 2024, 01:24:25 pm
I once tried buying a bus ticket in Wales, with a Scottish ten pound note. The driver let me on for free anyway.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Mr Larrington on 15 April, 2024, 02:36:02 pm
A former cow-orker used never to have a ticket on his Billericay<->Londonton commute, reckoning it was cheaper to pay the fine on the rare occasions he got nabbed than to cough up in the accepted manner.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: fimm on 15 April, 2024, 03:06:19 pm
My local station is unstaffed, but has ticket machines. It is the last station before you get to Waverley. and I think most if not all of the other stations on the line are similarly unstaffed. When you get to Waverley, there usually are no barriers, but in rush hour there are ticket checks and if you don't already have a ticket you can buy one, and you just say where you have come from.
Occasionally there are railway staff at my station who will insist on selling you a ticket before you get on to the platform. When I asked why, it was explained that if anyone attempted to claim that they had only travelled from there, they would be done for fare dodging, as no-one who got on that train at that station would be without a ticket.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Asterix, the former Gaul. on 15 April, 2024, 03:09:17 pm
I do know an accountant who was sacked for fare dodging. 

It hurt their career significantly.

A good accountant is one that always gets away with their misdeeds?
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: rogerzilla on 15 April, 2024, 05:17:28 pm
Quote
Three Scousers and three Mancs are travelling by train to a football match in London. At the station, the three Mancs each buy a ticket and watch as the three Scousers buy just one ticket between them.
"How are the three of you going to travel on only one ticket?" asks one of the Mancs.
"Watch and leam," answers one of the Scousers.
They all board the train. The Mancs take their respective seats but all three Scousers cram into a toilet and close the door behind them. Shortly after the train has departed, the conductor arrives to collect the tickets. He knocks on the toilet door and says, "Ticket please."
The door opens just a crack and a single arm emerges with a ticket in hand. The conductor takes it and moves on. The Mancs are mightily impressed by this, so after the game, they decide to copy the Scousers on the return trip and save some money. When they get to the station, they buy a single ticket for the return trip... To their astonishment, the Scousers don't buy a ticket at all!
"How are you going to travel without a ticket?" asks one perplexed Mancunian.
"Watch and leam..." says one Scouser.
When they board the train the three Mancs cram into a toilet and soon after the three Scousers pile into another nearby. The train departs. Shortly afterwards, one of the Scousers leaves the toilet and sneaks across to the toilet where the Mancs are hiding. He knocks on the door and says, "Ticket please..."
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: mrcharly-YHT on 15 April, 2024, 06:39:31 pm
I used to commute York to London regularly. 6 AM train out of york, Saver ticket.

Then they changed it, you could only use full fare on the 6am.

However; a return Saver was valid.

Next time down in london, I bought a Saver return at KX. The following morning, used the return portion on the 6am and the outward portion in the evening.

Not exactly fare dodging, but using a cheaper fare.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Nuncio on 15 April, 2024, 06:55:43 pm
A friend recently thought he'd got away with a free bus ride in Manchester when the driver said he couldn't change his £20 note but told to take a seat anyway. Except shortly into the ride the bus stopped outside a newsagent and the driver told him he'd wait while he went in to buy a Mars bar and get some change.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: robgul on 15 April, 2024, 06:57:09 pm
I used to commute York to London regularly. 6 AM train out of york, Saver ticket.

Then they changed it, you could only use full fare on the 6am.

However; a return Saver was valid.

Next time down in london, I bought a Saver return at KX. The following morning, used the return portion on the 6am and the outward portion in the evening.

Not exactly fare dodging, but using a cheaper fare.

I did exactly that when I used to travel back and forth to London from either Swindon or Birmingham 2 or 3 times a week - worked a treat to save cash.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Feanor on 15 April, 2024, 07:15:25 pm
I've always been slightly surprised how the ticket inspectors work on the LNER services.

These are long Azuma trains, running from Aberdeen down (or 'up', if you prefer in railway-language!) to London, and beyond.
The train makes reasonably frequent stops in Scotland, before zooming down to York and then London.

The inspector will walk through the carriage, shouting 'any tickets from Montrose, or Arbroath?'
If you have joined the train at those last two stops, you offer up your tickets.
Otherwise, you just look away.
Can these guys really have such good facial memory that they can glance at all the look-away-ers on a train that size,and think 'Oh, yea. I remember them. They got on at Stonehaven. I got them already.'?

I suppose they rely on honesty and ticket barriers at the main stations.

Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: JonBuoy on 15 April, 2024, 08:04:20 pm
The current price of a ticket on the 1900 from Sheffield to Loughborough on Wednesday is £6.70.  The first stop is at Chesterfield.  The current price of a ticket on the 1912 from Chesterfield to Loughborough is £10.80.  Should I feel bad about buying a ticket from Sheffield but saving them the trouble of having to transport me from Sheffield to Chesterfield?
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 15 April, 2024, 08:20:45 pm
Railways are full of anomalies like that. Once I was heading back home from Ashchurch (ie Tewkesbury) and decided rather than go into the centre of Bristol I'd get off a stop early at Filton Abbey Wood then ride from there, and if I saved myself a quid or two in the process, all the better. Turned out to cost more! And the reason is that the fare from Bristol Temple Meads is set by GWR, while the fare from Filton Abbey Wood is set by Cross Country, who are more price-gougey. What makes it really weird is that there are no Cross Country trains stopping at Filton.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: JonBuoy on 15 April, 2024, 08:23:35 pm
My example is EMR with no changes  ???
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Cudzoziemiec on 15 April, 2024, 08:26:32 pm
I'm sure there is a reason somewhere, recorded in a dusty filing cabinet by a Victorian clerk and kept in a dark cellar ever since.
Title: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: ScottishGeek on 15 April, 2024, 08:44:13 pm
When my wife and I were in San Francisco around 10 years ago we hopped on to one of the cable cars, a must for any visitor.

It was very busy and, as it set off, were asked to change our position a little by the driver. We happily obliged and thought nothing of it. Turned out the ticket  officer had just ‘cleared’ the area we moved into. We realised that he wasn’t coming back as we neared our stop, so tried to attract his attention in order to pay. He just waved us away and carried on as he had been doing.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: barakta on 15 April, 2024, 08:44:28 pm
I didn't go out of my way to talk to bus drivers as a kid if my clipper-card didn't work in the machine and there was a scrum boarding, or our weekly pass thermally faded sooner than it should. Drivers were rude and surly a lot of the time so it wasn't worth the hassle of talking to them unless you had to.

I don't think I've ever intentionally fare dodged onna train, but if I can't legit buy a ticket and then there's no gate at my destination I won't go out of my way. Especially not after a ticket let me into the system but then trapped me on the Underground at Euston at the last but one part of my return journey and staff wouldn't let me out or open a kiosk so I could pay. There was confusion about whether my ticket included transfer on the underground (you couldn't transfer otherwise so ????!). After 20 mins of banging on the kiosk window (staff were there but ignoring me), getting sore legs and risking missing my train, I told the gate staff "Either make those kiosk people let me pay Right Now, let me out, or I'm climbing this gate and you can call the police cos this is kidnap over a confusing shitty ticket system and I'm out of fucks". They let me out cos they could see I'd tried. I was NOT happy at all.

UK train ticketing is overly complicated, lots of expensive pitfalls and quite frankly sometimes horrid attitude in announcements and by staff towards passengers who are now confused by said shitty systems. I think tickets should be simplified and a lot cheaper and there should be a lot more capacity. People's cars don't decide to make their journey cost 10-20x more at certain times of day (usually) and car drivers aren't stuck on cold windy dieselly platforms for hours waiting for a seat, if they're lucky.

UK trains stink and I worry the Tories are going to try and make them worse.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Feanor on 15 April, 2024, 08:57:34 pm
When my wife and I were in San Francisco around 10 years ago we hopped on to one of the cable cars, a must for any visitor.

It was very busy and, as it set off, were asked to change our position a little by the driver. We happily obliged and thought nothing of it. Turned out the ticket  officer had just ‘cleared’ the area we moved into. We realised that he wasn’t coming back as we neared our stop, so tried to attract his attention in order to pay. He just waved us away and carried on as he had been doing.

These days, you buy your ticket using an app.
It was called MuniMobile when I was there a few months back.

Which was a bit annoying, since the other public transport (BART : Bay Area Rapid Transit, their underground/overground metro system, and several ferries) used the Clipper system, where you could add a clipper card ( like an Oyster card ) to your phone wallet.

So yet more crap on the phone...


Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Polar Bear on 15 April, 2024, 10:00:29 pm
I didn't go out of my way to talk to bus drivers as a kid if my clipper-card didn't work in the machine and there was a scrum boarding, or our weekly pass thermally faded sooner than it should. Drivers were rude and surly a lot of the time so it wasn't worth the hassle of talking to them unless you had to.

I don't think I've ever intentionally fare dodged onna train, but if I can't legit buy a ticket and then there's no gate at my destination I won't go out of my way. Especially not after a ticket let me into the system but then trapped me on the Underground at Euston at the last but one part of my return journey and staff wouldn't let me out or open a kiosk so I could pay. There was confusion about whether my ticket included transfer on the underground (you couldn't transfer otherwise so ????!). After 20 mins of banging on the kiosk window (staff were there but ignoring me), getting sore legs and risking missing my train, I told the gate staff "Either make those kiosk people let me pay Right Now, let me out, or I'm climbing this gate and you can call the police cos this is kidnap over a confusing shitty ticket system and I'm out of fucks". They let me out cos they could see I'd tried. I was NOT happy at all.

UK train ticketing is overly complicated, lots of expensive pitfalls and quite frankly sometimes horrid attitude in announcements and by staff towards passengers who are now confused by said shitty systems. I think tickets should be simplified and a lot cheaper and there should be a lot more capacity. People's cars don't decide to make their journey cost 10-20x more at certain times of day (usually) and car drivers aren't stuck on cold windy dieselly platforms for hours waiting for a seat, if they're lucky.

UK trains stink and I worry the Tories are going to try and make them worse.

You make a strong point about the cost.  I worked out that the train for us to visit Windermere in the Lake District will cost £140 for the two of us even with my disabled persons Railcard giving a third off for myself and my "helper".   It would cost about a tenner in electricity assuming a full charge when leaving home and plugging in on a public charger in Windermere to get the car back to 80% for the return leg.

The horrible thing of course is that mllePB would have to driven those 360 miles round trip.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: cygnet on 15 April, 2024, 10:07:58 pm
TL;DR
Everyone replying is agreed that fare dodging is bad, but sometimes the transport service, or ticket validation system is not 100%
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: cygnet on 15 April, 2024, 10:19:05 pm
I've never boarded public transport with the intent of not paying the fare.

I have been fined twice.

Both times it has been more cost effective to pay the fine than contest it.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: cygnet on 15 April, 2024, 10:30:29 pm
Can these guys really have such good facial memory that they can glance at all the look-away-ers on a train that size,and think 'Oh, yea. I remember them.
I suspect they do it more on spacial memory (block colour/form and location)
Next time try moving a carriage and taking off your coat; see if they still ignore your ignoring.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Basil on 15 April, 2024, 10:39:03 pm
When I applied for a Welsh bus pass I was supposed to surrender my English one.
I didn't, and would use it on visits to my mum in Reading and my son in Birmingham.
Sorry. Not Sorry.
It has date expired now.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Wowbagger on 15 April, 2024, 11:13:49 pm
When I think of the occasional shocking treatment I have had at the hands of rail companies/employees, I think fare dodging can be laudable.

Example: whilst travelling from Glasgow to Edinburgh prior to catching the 5.30 to London, I lost our tickets, for a friend, Jan and me. They cost me £42 and were seat/train specific. I had photographed them. The woman at Waverley station insisted I bought new tickets at £302. Even if someone had found and tried to use the originals, they would have been caught red-handed because we were sitting in the reserved seats.

In the end, karma prevailed: someone had been nicking copper in the Newark area and our train, which should have arrived at about 10pm, arrived after 3am. I claimed back both sets of tickets under the “delay repay” scheme, and the TOC tried to fob me off with £344 in vouchers. I took them to a small claims court and won, so eventually received a cheque for £344. It wasn’t long after this that the TOCs’ terms and conditions were changed and passengers were entitled to claim cash back for delay/repay instead of vouchers. I like to think that I contributed towards that rule change.


Edit: link to my account of the above exchange written at the time. https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=40489.msg920623#msg920623
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: perpetual dan on 15 April, 2024, 11:24:28 pm
I used the bus between Victoria and Marylebone quite a few times before I got checked and told that my cross London ticket wasn't valid on the bus. Still seems odd to me that one bit of London Transport is allowed and another (in this case, simpler) bit isn't. But it wasn't knowing or deliberate.

Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Wowbagger on 15 April, 2024, 11:26:49 pm
Example two: not long ago I took my bike on the train from Prittlewell to Wickford. Prittlewell now has a ticket machine but it is supposed to be manned from 6am to 1pm. This would have been about 9am and the ticket seller was absent. The ticket office was locked.

The machine was out of order. Another passenger, whom I didn’t know, was panicking about the thought of boarding a train without a ticket, even though there was no means to buy one. Something about her attitude made me, on the spur of the moment, take a photo of the offending machine.

When we got to Wickford, there about 5 ticket inspectors checking the tickets of everyone who got off the train. Those of us who had boarded at Prittlewell had none of course. The passenger in front of me was being treated like a criminal for not having a ticket - the full works. At that point I stepped in with my photo of the out of order machine.

I could see how miffed these inspectors were that I had “shot their fox” as it were, and one of them accompanied us to the Wickford ticket office to ensure that we bought tickets.

If one of those 5 inspectors had boarded a train to Prittlewell (17 minute journey) they could have arranged to have the ticket office opened and sold tickets, instead of harassing innocent passengers.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: barakta on 16 April, 2024, 12:58:33 am
I always take pictures of broken machines if I can't get tix another way, it's all evidence and if I was harassed by inspectors being unreasonable, I'd refuse to pay for new tickets and show the police my picture and fight the claim on sheer belligerence purposes.

The only time I remember a broken machine + unstaffed station I was anxious but when I explained to inspector he was fine and lovely and said he didn't need to see my pic cos the machine was ALWAYS breaking and he was happy to sell me the same ticket on board without being an arse.

You'd think if there's a broken machine they'd be able to say "OK everyone from broke-machine location come here" and see a group and not assume ALL of them were ticket dodging. They could even go and verify and fix the machine perhaps. Radical thought.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: mrcharly-YHT on 16 April, 2024, 08:03:01 am
Poppleton to York

It is a 5 min journey.

They closed the ticket office at poppleton and replaced it with a machine. Said machine would break down regularly,usually because someone shoved chewing gum in the slot.

Ticket inspectors knew this, and really could not be bothered to try to get people to pay in the 5min it took to get to York. They usually shut themselves in their cabin.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Asterix, the former Gaul. on 16 April, 2024, 08:16:45 am
I always take pictures of broken machines if I can't get tix another way, it's all evidence and if I was harassed by inspectors being unreasonable, I'd refuse to pay for new tickets and show the police my picture and fight the claim on sheer belligerence purposes.

The only time I remember a broken machine + unstaffed station I was anxious but when I explained to inspector he was fine and lovely and said he didn't need to see my pic cos the machine was ALWAYS breaking and he was happy to sell me the same ticket on board without being an arse.

You'd think if there's a broken machine they'd be able to say "OK everyone from broke-machine location come here" and see a group and not assume ALL of them were ticket dodging. They could even go and verify and fix the machine perhaps. Radical thought.

What would Paula Vennells have done?
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: orienteer on 16 April, 2024, 10:51:01 am
Almost every time I use the underground from Uxbridge I see fare dodgers just forcing their way through the wider gates. I think the usual station staff are instructed not to try and apprehend them, but occasionally there are fare enforcement staff and/or British Transport police there.

Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Pedal Castro on 16 April, 2024, 11:05:45 am
I can remember as a child (age 11) using a bus to get to school until I was given a bike for my birthday. Occasionally I would pick up a discarded ticket from the floor and fiddle with it, avoiding the gaze of the conductor when he came up to the top deck he (or she) never asked me to buy a ticket. Not sure how often I did this, maybe 3-4 times... I was a bit naughty then.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: gibbo on 16 April, 2024, 03:27:05 pm
A cycling friend of mine is a train inspector for Greater Anglia. He's had many encounters with fare dodgers, some resulting in personal injury.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: Jurek on 16 April, 2024, 05:28:48 pm
A cycling friend of mine is a train inspector for Greater Anglia. He's had many encounters with fare dodgers, some resulting in personal injury.
I've never encountered so many ticket inspectors on a particular TOC as I have with Greater Angrier.
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: JefO on 16 April, 2024, 07:54:41 pm
I enjoy it when the bus driver decides he/she doesn't want my payment. I would not knowingly avoid paying though.

It's only £2 and already cheaper than just starting a car. If payment for parking would otherwise be involved at the end of the journey, then the fare represents even better value to me. But getting it for nothing is always a pleasure!

I get my bus pass next year, and retired long ago, have been drawing a pension for 15 years that I paid into when fully expecting to get a state pension aged 65, so would be getting free travel now if the rules had stayed the same. So it feels like retribution!
Title: Re: Fare dodging: have you ever done it and is it ever acceptable?
Post by: PaulF on 16 April, 2024, 10:38:55 pm
A cycling friend of mine is a train inspector for Greater Anglia. He's had many encounters with fare dodgers, some resulting in personal injury.
I've never encountered so many ticket inspectors on a particular TOC as I have with Greater Angrier.

We had an infestation this morning in Oxford; they separated into groups and got onto different trains.

I’m assuming they were heading for their spawning grounds.