Why is society prepared to accept that some schools are 'better'? Shouldn't all schools be excellent?
Even with all public schools here being comprehensives, there's still "good" and "bad" schools.
But then the schools have their own employed pool of staff, so the 3 schools in North East Fife (Madras, Bell Baxter (boo hiss), Wade (booooooo))* can attract better teachers than those in say Levenmouth, because well you're mostly going to be dealing with kids with a considerably different outlook on life.
Same in Dundee, there's 3 good non-dom schools (Grove, Harris and Morgan) in the more affluent areas and the good Catholic school is St Johns with St Pauls being an amalgmation of Lawside and St Saviours which were both rough schools.
But then it only takes 1 head teacher change to wreck that **
* Take a guess which one I went to
** See Madras under Lindsay Matheson as an example