Benotto cello tape: stays clean, lasts a very long time, slippery (wear mitts/gloves if that's problem), looks good.
Cotton tape: good grip, feels nice, gets dirty, doesn't long as long, looks good.
Funnily enough, yesterday as I was looking for my spare brake blocks (Super/Nuovo Record), I opened a tool box to see 4 sets of actual "Shiny Tape" made in Taiwan tape, and 3 sets of 3ttt branded cello tape, all white (actually slightly off white but it's called white). It seems white is hard to find now, because it was the most popular colour by far.
I've also got more than 2 boxes of Tressostar white cotton tape (10 rolls in one box I think or maybe it's 20, I can't remember).
All bought very cheap, and enough to see me out.
I would think "Benotto" tape was originally made in Italy, but were later made in Mexico.