The old plastic Zefal analogue one I have is light and works well, albeit while removing a bit of air in the process, like all seperate gauges have to. (I can't find Presta versions of it online, unfortunately, only other models that I can't vouch for).
A properly inflated wide tyre* shouldn't feel all that different from a properly inflated narrow tyre** anyway because you're feeling the casing tension rather than the air pressure directly. Personally, I trust my thumbs more than what's written on the tyre. Of course they're only good through experience.
* ie. at low psi.
** ie. at high psi.