Yet Another Cycling Forum

General Category => Audax => PBP => Topic started by: Ajax Bay on 06 December, 2022, 11:46:59 am

Title: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 06 December, 2022, 11:46:59 am
https://www.paris-brest-paris.org/reglement/
https://www.paris-brest-paris.org/en/rules/
1. Dates: August 20-24, 2023
2. Requirement: Over 18 and a BRM SR completed.
3. Totals: "The number of starters will be limited to 8000. 2500 slots with be reserved for candidates of French nationality."
4. Pre-registrations from 14 Jan onwards, "date depends on the longest [BRM or LRM] brevet in 2022" (1 Nov 21 - 31 Oct 22, I think). Pre-registrations will be cancelled on 20 Jun if the [actual] registration was not initiated (at least three BRM must be given in the registration form).
5. Actual registration: You can register as soon as you have completed at least three qualifying brevets. For those not pre-registered, registration opens on 3 Jun, subject to 8000/5500/2500 limits. Registrations have to be completed (ie adding 4th brevet) by 2 Jul.
6. Entry fees: The preregistration fee is €50, non-refundable and deducted from the final registration fee. Le montant de l’inscription est de ??? euros. Réduction de 20 euros pour les licenciés FFCT.
Bottle, reflective gilet, finish meal and medal included.
7. Cancellation:  . . .
8. Bike rules:
9. Hi-vis&reflective vest (EN 1150 or EN ISO 20471) MUST be worn at night, iaw French Law.
10. Controls all the same (per 2019).
11. Insurance: Riders . . .  commit to being covered by insurance, including repatriation medical assistance.
12. Tracking/brevet: Electronic tracking as previous. Must get stamp in brevet at all controls (obv). Recommended to take a passport photo for brevet.
13a. Sign-in (ie before start): Day before start: receive brevet frame badge and other items. Option on Friday pm.
Sunday 1600: 80 hour limit
Sunday 1730-2100: 90 hour limit
Monday 0500: 84 hour limit
13b. Bike and vest check: 30 to 60 minutes before start: lighting and hi-vis/reflective vests checked.
14. Control times: "Respect the closing times. "Only a serious material incident may be accepted as justification for late arrival, and the delay must be recovered at the latest within the next two checkpoints."
15. Homologation & DNFs
16. Medical Test: "A medical test may be requested by the French State Secretary of Sport . . . Refusal to undergo this control or a positive test outcome will result in disqualification"
17. Support vehicles: None stopped on nor driving on route. Arrangements for them in/by/within 5km of controls.
19. Don't litter.

Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Roberto on 06 December, 2022, 11:54:47 am
Any idea what the various dates are for pre registration? I thought I had seen it somewhere but can't find it, I completed a 600km last season so just wanting to mark the date in my diary.

Cheers
Roberto
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 06 December, 2022, 04:12:15 pm
How about looking at the rulz (Rule 4 - see my post)? Use links at the top of post.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Roberto on 07 December, 2022, 07:10:51 am
I get that but it says from 14th January onwards, the last PBP had slightly different dates depending on whether you had ridden a 1000k,600k,400k etc the previous season. Hence why I mentioned my longest ride was a 600k.

Cheers
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: felstedrider on 07 December, 2022, 07:48:31 am
I get that but it says from 14th January onwards, the last PBP had slightly different dates depending on whether you had ridden a 1000k,600k,400k etc the previous season. Hence why I mentioned my longest ride was a 600k.

Cheers

Article 4.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: John Stonebridge on 07 December, 2022, 09:30:21 am
Any idea what the various dates are for pre registration? I thought I had seen it somewhere but can't find it, I completed a 600km last season so just wanting to mark the date in my diary.

Cheers
Roberto

28th Jan Robert.

Its #4 in the 2nd link.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 07 December, 2022, 09:45:09 am
Roberto probably wants to know the earliest preregistration date for each prequalified ride distance, particularly for the 600km prequalified folk.

It will be at two-week intervals for each reduction in prequalifier distance but it doesn’t actually matter.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 07 December, 2022, 10:20:03 am
Roberto probably wants to know the earliest preregistration date for each prequalified ride distance, particularly for the 600km prequalified folk.

It will be at two-week intervals for each reduction in prequalifier distance but it doesn’t actually matter.

and that is all in the link

1000 km or RM 1200 and +   January 14, 2023
600 km   January 28, 2023
400 km   February 11, 2023
300 km   February 25, 2023
200 km   March 11, 2023

So January 14th for all LEL finishers ;D
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Roberto on 07 December, 2022, 01:14:41 pm
Thanks for the replies, yes it does help if I follow the links ....doh!

My only excuse is that I'm in the middle of moving house so my head is up my arse at the moment,  getting too old for this moving malarkey 😒

I'll now put the 28th of January in my diary before I forget!!!
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: aidan.f on 13 December, 2022, 09:45:46 pm
Last time, rule 8 was 'extension bars must not project beyond brakes . I cut mine down. No one checked.. riding my trike so may chance it a bit this time, especially as the bars relive my arthritis...
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: grams on 14 December, 2022, 09:20:03 am
The rule on aero bars is:
Quote
For safety reasons, the use of extenders is strongly disadvised in peloton
(The French is pretty much the same)

So you can fit what you like, just don’t use them when riding in a big group.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: cygnet on 14 December, 2022, 08:24:06 pm
Rule 2 Insistence on an SR is not quite right and longer distances can be substituted as per the link and https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=124436.0 (https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=124436.0)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 15 December, 2022, 11:26:01 pm
Rule 2 Insistence on an SR is not quite right and longer distances can be substituted as per the link and https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=124436.0 (https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=124436.0)
Thank you so much for pointing that out. Most useful. I suggest a more authoritative link (rather than a random yacf thread) is https://www.paris-brest-paris.org/en/rules/ (second line of my OP).
SR: https://www.audax.uk/results/achievement-awards/randonneur-awards/
"The Super Randonneur award was established by ACP in 1977 and is the ‘gold standard’ award. It consists of the BR(M) series: 200 km, 300 km, 400 km, 600 km, all completed in the same Randonneur year. A longer distance can be substituted for a shorter."
So anyone who wants to ride, inter alia, must have completed a BRM/LRM SR within the dates individually set by national organisations (ACP correspondents).
Given I was trying to keep it as short as reasonable @cygnet, I suggest the précis of  Rule 2 in my OP "Requirement: Over 18 and an SR completed" is 'fit for purpose' and will pass the bike and vest/gilet check.

Separately I've just received this message from ACP's grande fromage:
Letter to former participants of the PBP 2019
You have successfully participated in Paris-Brest-Paris 2019.
If you would like to take part in the next edition either as a participant or as a volunteer, here is the following information:
• On Saturday January 7, 2023, the next edition will be presented: see the invitation card attached,
• If you want to join the organization team and take part in the party, directly at the heart of the event, you must register on the Qo-ezion platform made available. This solution allows us to be in phase with the regulations on the holding of personal information: identity, skills, preferred areas of activity, availability. Knowledge of this information will allow the organization to better manage missions.
Here is the website dedicated to staffing: https://www.instantsbenevoles.fr/evenement/
The Audax Club Parisien thanks you for your commitment and for agreeing to send this URL to your friends.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: jsabine on 22 December, 2022, 12:06:35 am
Rule 2 Insistence on an SR is not quite right and longer distances can be substituted as per the link and https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=124436.0 (https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=124436.0)
Thank you so much for pointing that out. Most useful. I suggest a more authoritative link (rather than a random yacf thread) is https://www.paris-brest-paris.org/en/rules/ (second line of my OP).
SR: https://www.audax.uk/results/achievement-awards/randonneur-awards/
"The Super Randonneur award was established by ACP in 1977 and is the ‘gold standard’ award. It consists of the BR(M) series: 200 km, 300 km, 400 km, 600 km, all completed in the same Randonneur year. A longer distance can be substituted for a shorter."
So anyone who wants to ride, inter alia, must have completed a BRM/LRM SR within the dates individually set by national organisations (ACP correspondents).
Given I was trying to keep it as short as reasonable @cygnet, I suggest the précis of  Rule 2 in my OP "Requirement: Over 18 and an SR completed" is 'fit for purpose' and will pass the bike and vest/gilet check.

cygnet's dead right.

An ACP/BRM SR is exactly 200/300/400/600. For the purposes of PBP qualification, you can substitute a longer distance ride, but then it's not an SR and you won't get an SR medal, or at least I didn't in 2015 or 2019.

An AUK SR does allow you to substitute longer distances (which of course might all be BRMs ...).
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: caferaca on 15 January, 2023, 08:46:59 am
The rule on aero bars is:
Quote
For safety reasons, the use of extenders is strongly disadvised in peloton
(The French is pretty much the same)

So you can fit what you like, just don’t use them when riding in a big group.

This is good to know. I suffered nerve damage in my hands on LEL last year (they are still not right!), and was planning on using aero bars for PBP to take the pressure off. Obviously wouldn't use them in a group.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: frillipippi on 20 February, 2023, 04:44:43 pm
I have a doubt about article 10: when it says "Riders must stay on the official route", does it mean that you can't abandon it all, not even to get to a supermarket or a B&B or a hotel (or simply by mistake), or is it just that in such circumstances you have to get back to the point where you left the official route and in the meanwhile the insurance doesn't cover?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: felstedrider on 20 February, 2023, 04:49:12 pm
I have a doubt about article 10: when it says "Riders must stay on the official route", does it mean that you can't abandon it all, not even to get to a supermarket or a B&B or a hotel (or simply by mistake), or is it just that in such circumstances you have to get back to the point where you left the official route and in the meanwhile the insurance doesn't cover?

In practice you *should* rejoin the route at the point you left.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 20 February, 2023, 09:56:52 pm
I have a doubt about article 10: when it says "Riders must stay on the official route", does it mean that you can't abandon it all, not even to get to a supermarket or a B&B or a hotel (or simply by mistake), or is it just that in such circumstances you have to get back to the point where you left the official route and in the meanwhile the insurance doesn't cover?

In theory you *should* rejoin the route at the point you left.
FTFY @frillipippi Noone GAF. What benefits do you think 'the insurance' affords that your personal travel or other insurance does not cover far better?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: frillipippi on 21 February, 2023, 06:46:12 am
I have a doubt about article 10: when it says "Riders must stay on the official route", does it mean that you can't abandon it all, not even to get to a supermarket or a B&B or a hotel (or simply by mistake), or is it just that in such circumstances you have to get back to the point where you left the official route and in the meanwhile the insurance doesn't cover?

In theory you *should* rejoin the route at the point you left.
FTFY @frillipippi Noone GAF. What benefits do you think 'the insurance' affords that your personal travel or other insurance does not cover far better?
The way article 10 is written, especially in the French version, links "Riders must stay on the official route" to insurance consequences of a breach.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Lightning Phil on 22 February, 2023, 01:16:00 pm
No one is going to blink if you leave the route  to go to a shop, booked hotel etc. Just return to route from whence you left it.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 23 February, 2023, 12:29:49 pm
I have a doubt about article 10: when it says "Riders must stay on the official route", does it mean that you can't abandon it all, not even to get to a supermarket or a B&B or a hotel (or simply by mistake), or is it just that in such circumstances you have to get back to the point where you left the official route and in the meanwhile the insurance doesn't cover?

In theory you *should* rejoin the route at the point you left.
FTFY @frillipippi Noone GAF. What benefits do you think 'the insurance' affords that your personal travel or other insurance does not cover far better?
The way article 10 is written, especially in the French version, links "Riders must stay on the official route" to insurance consequences of a breach.
The ACP/PBP organised insurance is for 'material damage or personal injury caused to a third party by a participant.'
This will covered by a rider's personal travel insurance 'as well' so deviating from the route (for the simple purposes described ^^^) will have no material effect on a rider's insurance position. As said, noone GAF, especially given any deviation will not offer advantage (remember the French attitude/context here).
#10/11 extract:
Article 10:
"Riders must stay on the official route. Please be aware that the insurance cover will be invalid if you deviate from the official route.
Article 11: Responsibilities and insurance
". . . cyclists participate in PBP at their own risk and that riders are not covered unless they have taken out an individual insurance. The participant commits to being covered by insurance when registering.
A « Responsabilité Civile – Défense & Recours » policy has been taken out by the organizers for the duration of the event, for all material or corporal damage caused to a third party by a participant."
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: CrazyEnglishTriathlete on 23 February, 2023, 01:49:04 pm
I wouldn't rely on event travel insurance.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: frillipippi on 23 February, 2023, 10:29:11 pm
Thank you very much for the clarification!
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: zacklaws on 25 February, 2023, 06:57:10 pm
I had nothing to do last night so I had a browse through everything in the PBP website especially the rules to make sure nothing had crept in since the last time I read them and could catch me out and noticed one rule that I had not noticed before, probably because I don't do it anyway so I took no notice of it was that amongst the "penalties" is use of a mobile phone whilst riding. Doing so incurs an hour time penalty.

I know from 2015 and 2019 a lot of riders do it taking selfies etc whilst riding or taking pictures of the group they are riding with

One of the things that stood out on LEL this year was an Indian rider who I kept bumping into, he was constantly riding along holding his phone above his head filming everything but at the same time looking upwards to make sure the phone was pointing in the right direction. Whilst he was doing he, he was drifting all over the road and cars coming up behind were having to brake to avoid him.  I kept my distance from him, especially in one village going up a hill and he was wobbling all over riding slow, trying to balance, looking upwards at the phone and just one hand on the bars.

I always cringe when I see someone doing it holding the phone up at front of the group to get a picture of those behind. It's just recipe for a crash. Maybe it has happened hence the time penalty for those who do it.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: felstedrider on 25 February, 2023, 08:00:39 pm
I seem to recall headphones being banned.  Despite them saving me from the dozies a few times I chose not to carry them in 2019 to avoid temptation.  Might be a French traffic reg actually.

The cover photo of Arrivee had a PBP rider wearing headphones, though, so I may be wrong.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 27 February, 2023, 06:11:06 am
Headphones and mobile phones are Fernch traffic law things.
The use of mobile phones while riding is already banned for several editions.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Frank9755 on 28 February, 2023, 02:21:55 pm
In-ear headphones are banned under French law.  Bone conducting ones are a grey area, though! 
Same for motorists. 
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LateStarter on 28 February, 2023, 09:12:25 pm
In-ear headphones are banned under French law. ……………. Same for motorists.

I am 100% in favour of banning motorists too!
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: frankly frankie on 07 March, 2023, 05:49:21 pm
... one rule that I had not noticed before, probably because I don't do it anyway so I took no notice of it was that amongst the "penalties" is use of a mobile phone whilst riding. Doing so incurs an hour time penalty.

I know from 2015 and 2019 a lot of riders do it taking selfies etc whilst riding or taking pictures of the group they are riding with

Does that count as 'use of a mobile phone' though?
What about using the phone as a GPS on the bars?  Same thing surely.

You could run it in airplane mode while doing these things and then have fun arguing the finer points of the law in French ...
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: CrazyEnglishTriathlete on 10 March, 2023, 10:12:54 am
I'd better take the penalty now then.  I use my mobile phone for step counting, a function it continues to do in my back pocket when cycling.   :facepalm:
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: CrazyEnglishTriathlete on 10 March, 2023, 10:14:00 am
Actually, and I think more in the spirit of the rules - the one thing it is pretty hopeless at is being a phone.  it turns conversations randomly into Dalek - a tongue in which I have no formal training and find unintelligble.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 13 March, 2023, 08:35:23 am
Besides the opportunity to pre-register with no BRM last year on 25 March (Monday starts only, assumed), Article 6 has also been amended to state the entry fee (due no later than 10 June (NB change) or pre-registration will be lost/cancelled).

"Article 6: Payment
"The pre-registration fee is €50, non-refundable and deducted from the final registration fee.
"The registration fee is €190."
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: JonBuoy on 13 March, 2023, 11:28:13 am
For reference - I believe that it was €145 in 2019.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Bianchi Boy on 16 March, 2023, 06:30:55 pm
Bike check on Saturday?

There only appears to be a collection of numbers and registration. It looks like the bike check has been changed to just before your off.

Is this correct?

BB
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 17 March, 2023, 08:30:50 am
Bike check on Saturday?

There only appears to be a collection of numbers and registration. It looks like the bike check has been changed to just before your off.

Is this correct?

BB

there was a lot of talk some months back about no bike check this time, but threat of impromptu inspections along the course. Always seemed like a waste of time. What are they looking for? people who can't reassemble their bikes safely after transport?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 17 March, 2023, 09:34:47 am
Bike check on Saturday?

There only appears to be a collection of numbers and registration. It looks like the bike check has been changed to just before your off.

Is this correct?

BB

there was a lot of talk some months back about no bike check this time, but threat of impromptu inspections along the course. Always seemed like a waste of time. What are they looking for? people who can't reassemble their bikes safely after transport?

Having done bike check at a smaller 1200, I can confirm that there are always a few participants with improperly prepared bikes. Mostly issues with lighting and items not being fastened well enough to the bike. This is, of course, best checked just before the start, as every bike is loaded up.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: zacklaws on 17 March, 2023, 10:09:25 am
For reference - I believe that it was €145 in 2019.

Just looked at my 2015 and 2019 paperwork, it was 135 euros 2019 and 115 euros 2015.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: zacklaws on 17 March, 2023, 10:47:55 am
Bike check on Saturday?

There only appears to be a collection of numbers and registration. It looks like the bike check has been changed to just before your off.

Is this correct?

BB

there was a lot of talk some months back about no bike check this time, but threat of impromptu inspections along the course. Always seemed like a waste of time. What are they looking for? people who can't reassemble their bikes safely after transport?

Having done bike check at a smaller 1200, I can confirm that there are always a few participants with improperly prepared bikes. Mostly issues with lighting and items not being fastened well enough to the bike. This is, of course, best checked just before the start, as every bike is loaded up.

Looking through the PBP website, I see the following: -

"Departure control:
It takes place in Rambouillet, between 30 and 60 minutes before the time of each departure. For better fluidity, please do not show up earlier. Reflective lights and vests will be checked during this check.

Warning: Any uncontrolled logbook and chip not registered at departure will result in the non-homologation of the patent"


This may well be the bike check, but when the 90 hr groups are departing with groups of 300+ that all sounds rather manic as in theory, they would be having to process at least 300+ riders every 15 minutes whether they turn up 15 mins or 60 mins early as that would be encroaching on other groups start times.

Basically, its probably just a "Ride Past" with lights on and wearing or carrying reflective vests and then you just carry on to join your group and wait for the start.

Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 17 March, 2023, 02:03:45 pm
Bike check on Saturday?
There only appears to be a collection of numbers and registration. It looks like the bike check has been changed to just before your off.
Is this correct?
If that first phrase is a question, the answer is 'no'.
Just down into the shed and collect stuff: numbered stuff, frame plate with transponder, a gilet as part of the entry fee, and other clothing if ordered.
ACP will have workable plan for checking bikes(lights) and gilets as riders enter the pens, Queuing mega-early will not help. 20 every minute is doable provided they have about 5 funnels and sensible mentally agile persons (need 10 pers at least to allow shifts as this is non-stop for 6 hours) giving the green light with a 'bon courage'. In that heat wave, many riders will not be wearing their boil-in-the-bag PBP gilets till maybe wave P onwards, unless Japanese (ime): in J last time we rode maybe 60km till a 'side-of-the-road' water top up could be combined with pulling on the gilet. I expect the check will be approached in a Gallic manner - apply own stereotype to that ;)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 29 March, 2023, 02:11:57 am

Having done bike check at a smaller 1200, I can confirm that there are always a few participants with improperly prepared bikes. Mostly issues with lighting and items not being fastened well enough to the bike. This is, of course, best checked just before the start, as every bike is loaded up.

I've done the bike check for a couple of ultras, and you'd be amazed what some people turn up with. I failed one bike cos it had loose QR skewers. "But I like to ride loose" "tighten them, or you're not riding". Not to mention the number of people who didn't bring everything (helmet, lights, hivis) to the bike check, despite the instructions in the manual. Special shout-out to the guy who forgot to bring his bike... And the one who only brought one wheel...

J

Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 29 March, 2023, 12:16:11 pm

Having done bike check at a smaller 1200, I can confirm that there are always a few participants with improperly prepared bikes. Mostly issues with lighting and items not being fastened well enough to the bike. This is, of course, best checked just before the start, as every bike is loaded up.

I've done the bike check for a couple of ultras, and you'd be amazed what some people turn up with. I failed one bike cos it had loose QR skewers. "But I like to ride loose" "tighten them, or you're not riding". Not to mention the number of people who didn't bring everything (helmet, lights, hivis) to the bike check, despite the instructions in the manual. Special shout-out to the guy who forgot to bring his bike... And the one who only brought one wheel...
I guess this reinforces the merit of an 'immediately pre-start' bike check (much reduced logistic and check-in burden for both ACP and every rider).
The bike will be complete in all respects and if there are deficiencies, the rider's start will be delayed while remediated. This should be deterrent enough to the careless ones. And for PBP every rider has completed an SR in the months before August, one assumes their bike got them round.
Perhaps ACP can/should set up a stall near the start with EN-compliant gilets, lights and helmets for sale for those determined to test the system (well, no, not helmets).
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 30 March, 2023, 09:55:13 am


 I failed one bike cos it had loose QR skewers. "But I like to ride loose" "tighten them, or you're not riding".


reminds me of the time I thought I needed to tighten the headset as there seemed to be some play, only to discover the thu-axle wasn't quite tight.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 04 May, 2023, 01:23:03 pm
Is this a new requirement?

Quote
Tracking/brevet: Electronic tracking as previous. Must get stamp in brevet at all controls (obv). Recommended to take a passport photo for brevet.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 04 May, 2023, 01:45:10 pm
I recall needing passport photos a few PBPs ago.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 06 May, 2023, 10:20:10 pm
Is this a new requirement?
Quote
"Tracking/brevet: Electronic tracking as previous. Must get stamp in brevet at all controls (obv). Recommended to take a passport photo for brevet."
Think I took one and stuck it in last time.
"Nous vous conseillons de coller une photo d’identité récente sur le carnet de route (format 35 x 25 mm)."
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 09 May, 2023, 07:24:31 am
I must have missed that rule. I didn't take one, and nobody asked to see one.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Flâneur on 26 May, 2023, 11:43:02 am
Re bike check - am reading that orange wheel/side reflectors and a bell/horn are mandatory under French law - is that correct? If so, I'd probably take my chances with Les Gendarmes/Police Nationale, but do they form part of the bike check?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 26 May, 2023, 12:10:41 pm
Re bike check - am reading that orange wheel/side reflectors and a bell/horn are mandatory under French law - is that correct? If so, I'd probably take my chances with Les Gendarmes/Police Nationale, but do they form part of the bike check?

They cost fuck all, they add very minimal weight. I'd just fit them.

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 26 May, 2023, 12:18:53 pm
Re bike check - am reading that orange wheel/side reflectors and a bell/horn are mandatory under French law - is that correct? If so, I'd probably take my chances with Les Gendarmes/Police Nationale, but do they form part of the bike check?
I suggest this mandate is approached in the traditional Gallic manner.
The bike check in 2019 in the marquee did not check either of those items (was just brakes and lights - seemed to me like 'make work' for keen old volunteer blokes to allow them to feel 'part of it').

ACP:"Bikes must be in compliance with French regulations. Bikes must possess a lighting system powerful enough to be seen at a distance of 100 m from the front and 150 m from the rear. It must be securely and permanently fixed on the bike, even during daytime, and in working order at any time. Flashing LEDs at the rear are forbidden.
"Start control: . . . from 30 to 60 minutes before . . . start. Lighting and reflective vests will be checked . .  "

Source: Legifrance Code de la Route - https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/texte_lc/LEGITEXT000006074228
Art. R.313-18. Every cycle must be equipped with one or more rear retro-reflectors.
Art. R.313-19. Every cycle must be equipped with orange reflectors visible laterally.
Art. R.313-20. The pedals of any cycle shall include retro-reflectors of the color orange. Every cycle must be equipped with a visible white reflector on the front.
Art. R.313-33. Every cycle must be equipped with a warning apparatus constituted by a bell whose sound may be heard at 50m at least.  Any other sound signal is prohibited.
They cost fuck all, they add very minimal weight. I'd just fit them.
We're riding to Brest and back, not round urban Paris. A rear reflector makes sense but normal road pedals don't have the reflectors incorporated: how do you propose you'd fit them J? And what are these laterally visible orange reflectors: reflectors fixed to spokes? Most of this is anti-aesthetically displeasing as well as a drag.
Bells are good through: the more sonorous the better, for enhancing the atmosphere and replying to the locals' 'bon courage'.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 26 May, 2023, 01:13:33 pm
I have ridden the last six PBPs and never had a check for reflectors or bell.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 26 May, 2023, 01:29:00 pm

They are a legal requirement in Netherlands, France, and Germany, plus no doubt others. As I say they cost very little, and they weigh fuck all. I'm not entirely sure what the aversion is.

Of all the stupid rules France has for bikes, this is the least objectionable of all of them.

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 26 May, 2023, 01:38:14 pm

For a fiver you can have a pair for each wheel:

https://bit.ly/3qgvkR6

Riding in a country where it feels like half the cyclists think lights are something they don't need, I have become a big fan of reflectors for avoiding crashing into them.

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 26 May, 2023, 01:49:13 pm
Given that every single PBPer will have front and rear lights on their bike and a reflective vest for night time use, requiring reflectors and a bell seems a little excessive.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 26 May, 2023, 01:52:28 pm
Given that every single PBPer will have front and rear lights on their bike and a reflective vest for night time use, requiring reflectors and a bell seems a little excessive.

It is a requirement of the law of the land tho, not a bonus requirement of the event.

Just be glad it's not like many ultra races that also require a shit ton of reflective stickers across the bike too...

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Flâneur on 26 May, 2023, 02:01:19 pm
Just be glad it's not like many ultra races that also require a shit ton of reflective stickers across the bike too...

I've got (some of) those mais ils ne sont pas oranges
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Lightning Phil on 26 May, 2023, 02:03:45 pm
Surely the Vienna Convention applies when it comes to bikes? In that case just the rear rear reflector, in addition to the lights. More difficult to do, if you don’t have mudguards on your bike.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 26 May, 2023, 02:06:45 pm
Just be glad it's not like many ultra races that also require a shit ton of reflective stickers across the bike too...

J

Just one of the reasons I don't do shit ultra races. I also enjoy riding with a cap, rather than a helmet, at PBP.

Given the reflector thing isn't enforced in France, I won't bother.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Graeme on 27 May, 2023, 09:37:29 am
Fyi if you do fancy pedal reflectors, SJS sell Shimano branded reflectors for SPD and SPD-SL. I can't afford the top tier Dura Ace reflectors, but I understand they actually make your bike lighter and more aerodynamic.

https://www.sjscycles.co.uk/search/?term=Pedal%20reflector
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 27 May, 2023, 10:09:35 am

Just one of the reasons I don't do shit ultra races. I also enjoy riding with a cap, rather than a helmet, at PBP.

Given the reflector thing isn't enforced in France, I won't bother.

What do you do when you ride in Australia?

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 27 May, 2023, 11:14:07 am
I sweat a lot and I complain, the same as I do at events that require helmets, but I prefer riding in a cycling cap. Mandatory helmets in Oz is one of the reasons I have ridden more 1000s/ 1200s in France than in Oz.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 27 May, 2023, 11:15:46 am
I sweat a lot and I complain, the same as I do at events that require helmets, but I prefer riding in a cycling cap. Mandatory helmets in Oz is one of the reasons I have ridden more 1000s/ 1200s in France than in Oz.

Why are you OK to follow the law of the land in Oz, but not to do so in France? Esp when doing so in France is so utterly benign.

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LateStarter on 27 May, 2023, 11:27:47 am
I sweat a lot and I complain, the same as I do at events that require helmets, but I prefer riding in a cycling cap. Mandatory helmets in Oz is one of the reasons I have ridden more 1000s/ 1200s in France than in Oz.

Why are you OK to follow the law of the land in Oz, but not to do so in France? Esp when doing so in France is so utterly benign.

J

Because in OZ No Helmet = about AUD500 fine , yes five hundred, (GBP 275, Euro 325), No Bell = AUD 150, No rear reflector = 300 ish (all vary between states), then you get into the serious stuff like no lights......did I mention Oz has a very low cycling participation rate, wonder why?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 27 May, 2023, 11:34:05 am
Because in OZ No Helmet = about AUD500 fine , yes five hundred, (GBP 275, Euro 325), No Bell = AUD 150, No rear reflector = 300 ish (all vary between states), then you get into the serious stuff like no lights......did I mention Oz has a very low cycling participation rate, wonder why?

So cos the fine in France is so low you feel that you can ignore the law of the land?

I assume you don't cycle in .NL or .DE ?

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 27 May, 2023, 11:51:42 am
I have ridden the Hamburg-Berlin-Koln-Hamburg 1500km brevet but have only rarely ridden in the Netherlands (300km BRM was the longest). I didn’t have wheel reflectors or a bell in either (or any) country.

Venturing into POBI territory, just because something is law doesn’t make it right.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 28 May, 2023, 02:23:51 pm
They are a legal requirement in Netherlands, France, and Germany, plus no doubt others. As I say they cost very little, and they weigh fuck all. I'm not entirely sure what the aversion is.
Of all the stupid rules France has for bikes, this is the least objectionable of all of them.
J
And one which is given a widespread Gallic ignoring, both by tens of thousands of riders from 'racing' to leisure and ignored by le police municipal and les gendarmerie. Fuss not. Many rear lights have a reflection element and otherwise a stand alone reflector or one on the mudguard sorts that element. A front reflector gets in the way of other necessary front end stuff, is just useless given effective lights and the French enforcers know it.
Which leaves the lateral reflectors (by law): what percentage of PBP riders are going to fit those to their spokes: only just up the spectrum from dork discs, but fine for children's leisure bikes, to keep 'mum' content, if she cares.
What other "stupid rules France has for bikes" that you think are more objectionable?
I echo LWaB's take.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 28 May, 2023, 02:30:48 pm

What other "stupid rules France has for bikes" that you think are more objectionable?


The mandatory high Vis, and the rule about not wearing headphones. The headphones one is the one I hate the most.

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Zed43 on 28 May, 2023, 04:56:40 pm
I won't be wearing the high-viz this time because it's ridiculous to do so in a velomobile, but obviously will have it at hand and use it when walking around at night. For most people, who more or less fit into the gilets, the high-viz will be bonus if the night temperature will be like last time 🥶

The no-headphone is a nuisance for me >:( I'll be wearing earplugs then to tone down the wind noise.

The velomobile will violate all but one requirements (it has a rear reflector); I may add bits of retro-reflecting foil on the front/sides though, that will be easy to do.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 28 May, 2023, 05:30:35 pm
I won't be wearing the high-viz this time because it's ridiculous to do so in a velomobile, but obviously will have it at hand and use it when walking around at night. For most people, who more or less fit into the gilets, the high-viz will be bonus if the night temperature will be like last time 🥶

The no-headphone is a nuisance for me >:( I'll be wearing earplugs then to tone down the wind noise.

The velomobile will violate all but one requirements (it has a rear reflector); I may add bits of retro-reflecting foil on the front/sides though, that will be easy to do.

Wait. when did you turn to the dark side ?

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Zed43 on 28 May, 2023, 06:25:38 pm
Wait. when did you turn to the dark side ?
April 11  ;D

3481km in the Snoek so far. There will be more kilometers in getting to/from Rambouillet than in riding PBP itself ;)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 28 May, 2023, 08:04:39 pm

What other "stupid rules France has for bikes" that you think are more objectionable?


The mandatory high Vis, and the rule about not wearing headphones. The headphones one is the one I hate the most.

J

I see the mandatory high vis as a necessary legal requirement to prevent car drivers walking away from close passes with 'I didn't see the cyclist'
(a close pass in France isn't considered a traffic offence anymore but punished under criminal law)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Tom on 29 May, 2023, 12:49:06 pm
Sorry if this has been covered before, but do any of the anciens know whether it's possible to pick up your start documents etc later on the Sunday than the midday or so cutoff shown on the website? I've got an early Monday start and had hoped to ride down from Dieppe on the Sunday (ferry arrives 0400)  - with the best will and most favourable wind, I'm not going to get to rambouillet before about 3 or 4pm. Alternatively, is it possible to ask another Monday morning starter to pick the bits up on my behalf? I realise I should probably address this to the horse's mouth, but thought I'd ask here first before embarrassing myself with my GCSE French.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 29 May, 2023, 01:25:33 pm
ACP is efficient in dealing with emails written in English.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Tom on 29 May, 2023, 01:51:10 pm
Thanks, I'll give that a go.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 30 May, 2023, 12:45:08 am

April 11  ;D

3481km in the Snoek so far. There will be more kilometers in getting to/from Rambouillet than in riding PBP itself ;)

Nice! Photos??

How are you finding it ?

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: thing1 on 30 May, 2023, 07:41:07 am
Have they published Brest cut off times yet? Or anyone care to share what they were last time around.
Specifically interested in the 84H rider's 600km allowance but having them all here in one place would be ace :)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 30 May, 2023, 09:15:29 am
Have they published Brest cut off times yet? Or anyone care to share what they were last time around.
Specifically interested in the 84H rider's 600km allowance but having them all here in one place would be ace :)

last time it was 42 hours for the 90hour group as I recall, so if you assume something around 39 hours for the 84 hour starts, you won't be far wrong.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 30 May, 2023, 09:30:26 am



Riding in a country where it feels like half the cyclists think lights are something they don't need, I have become a big fan of reflectors for avoiding crashing into them.

J

I think this is exactly the point, the requirement for reflectors is to deal with those that do not fit lights, or from a time when lights were less reliable. No self respecting randonneur is heading out without working lights, and the mandatory hi vis gilet will be enforced at the controls.

If shoes (or leg warmers/tights) have reflective elements, does it really add anything to have additional on the pedals? So that just leaves side reflectors on the wheels. I might see about digging some out, I think Canyon provided me with a set when I bought one of their bikes years ago. I never fitted them because they are just so pointless. So the chances of my fitting reflectors, spokey-dokes or dorc discs to my wheels is pretty low. I'd be more like to look for some schwalbe tyres with a refletive line running round the side wall.
Amazingly drivers can see cars from the side despite the lights only pointing front and back and no side reflectors. So why seeing bikes from this angle is difficult is a mystery. Perhaps it also stems from a time when bike lights gave off about as much light as half a candle.

Reflectors are a legal requirement in the UK too, but I have never heard of anyone being prosecuted for lack of reflectors IF they have a working set of lights. I think the only reflectors on any of my bikes are on the mudguards. (rear and side)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 30 May, 2023, 01:52:06 pm
Have they published Brest cut off times yet? Or anyone care to share what they were last time around.
Specifically interested in the 84H rider's 600km allowance but having them all here in one place would be ace :)

I can't remember what the control closing times were for PBP19 but https://rusa.org/pbp95checkpoints.html#84HR were the control closing times from last century, with about the same overall distance as PBP23. Brest closed 38-ish hours after starting from St Quentin en Yvelines back then. I rode the 84hr starts at PBP07 and PBP11 and sub-40 hours sounds about right from vague memory but watch the closing time at Carhaix outbound too. That seemed particularly tight. HK and I seemed to bounce along too close for my comfort to the 84hr closing times until Mortagne au Perche on the return but we made time hand over fist after that.

That is good enough for planning purposes at this stage.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: frillipippi on 31 May, 2023, 11:31:24 am
In addition to all mandatory (although not enforced) items and Schwalbe tyres, I've just had my bike painted in silver reflective paint because I'm convinced that the more visible you and your bike are, the better.

I'll claim more: being conspicuous is the new fashion, day and night.

So, if you're leaving Rambouillet in the first group, be sure to have your sunglasses with you, or ride in front of me!
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: thing1 on 31 May, 2023, 09:23:25 pm

I can't remember what the control closing times were for PBP19 but https://rusa.org/pbp95checkpoints.html#84HR were the control closing times from last century, with about the same overall distance as PBP23. Brest closed 38-ish hours after starting from St Quentin en Yvelines back then. I rode the 84hr starts at PBP07 and PBP11 and sub-40 hours sounds about right from vague memory but watch the closing time at Carhaix outbound too. That seemed particularly tight. HK and I seemed to bounce along too close for my comfort to the 84hr closing times until Mortagne au Perche on the return but we made time hand over fist after that.

That is good enough for planning purposes at this stage.

Good good, thank you. as you say that's plenty for planning purposes at this point. 👍
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: CrazyEnglishTriathlete on 31 May, 2023, 10:27:29 pm
In addition to all mandatory (although not enforced) items and Schwalbe tyres, I've just had my bike painted in silver reflective paint because I'm convinced that the more visible you and your bike are, the better.

I'll claim more: being conspicuous is the new fashion, day and night.

So, if you're leaving Rambouillet in the first group, be sure to have your sunglasses with you, or ride in front of me!

Likewise, I gave my new Rapha pink socks a trial run today.  They can be seen from 150m day or night :)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 31 May, 2023, 11:23:03 pm
Sorry if this has been covered before, but do any of the anciens know whether it's possible to pick up your start documents etc later on the Sunday than the midday or so cutoff shown on the website? I've got an early Monday start and had hoped to ride down from Dieppe on the Sunday (ferry arrives 0400)  - with the best will and most favourable wind, I'm not going to get to rambouillet before about 3 or 4pm. Alternatively, is it possible to ask another Monday morning starter to pick the bits up on my behalf? I realise I should probably address this to the horse's mouth, but thought I'd ask here first before embarrassing myself with my GCSE French.
where did you find this?

From the diary page of the presentation  https://www.paris-brest-paris.org/en/download/PBP-BROCHURE-PRESENTATION-EN.pdf I get
Quote
FRIDAY, AUGUST 18 /
SATURDAY, AUGUST 19 /
SUNDAY, AUGUST 20, 2023
Withdrawal of your documents
Friday from 2 pm to 7 pm or
Saturday from 8 am to 7 pm (if and only if you start on Sunday),
Sunday from 8 pm to 1 am (if and only if you start on Monday)
now 8pm to 1am seemed a bit unlikely to me, so i checked the French version
Quote
[VENDREDI 18 / SAMEDI 19 /
DIMANCHE 20 AOÛT 2023
retrait de votre dossier
le vendredi de 14h00 à 19h00
ou le samedi de 8h00 à 19h00 uniquement pour les partants du dimanche,
le dimanche de 8h00 à 13h00 uniquement pour les partants du lundi.
24 hour clock is less ambiguous, so you have until 13:00, that's 9 hours from your 4m arrival time to cover 180km. pretty tough if riding all loaded up for the event. I would be surprised if they allowed anyone to collect outside this window, or they will just end up with everyone turning up later. More chance of getting someone to collect for you

for those riding on Sunday, and cycling to Rambouillet, do you anticipate cycling on the Saturday? or having a rest day in Rambouillet after arrival?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Lightning Phil on 01 June, 2023, 09:20:54 pm
I’m riding down to Rambouillet over 2 days from Dieppe. I’ll be riding 70km on the Saturday.  Start 1715 on Sunday.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Tom on 01 June, 2023, 09:43:46 pm
Sorry if this has been covered before, but do any of the anciens know whether it's possible to pick up your start documents etc later on the Sunday than the midday or so cutoff shown on the website? I've got an early Monday start and had hoped to ride down from Dieppe on the Sunday (ferry arrives 0400)  - with the best will and most favourable wind, I'm not going to get to rambouillet before about 3 or 4pm. Alternatively, is it possible to ask another Monday morning starter to pick the bits up on my behalf? I realise I should probably address this to the horse's mouth, but thought I'd ask here first before embarrassing myself with my GCSE French.
where did you find this?

From the diary page of the presentation  https://www.paris-brest-paris.org/en/download/PBP-BROCHURE-PRESENTATION-EN.pdf I get
Quote
FRIDAY, AUGUST 18 /
SATURDAY, AUGUST 19 /
SUNDAY, AUGUST 20, 2023
Withdrawal of your documents
Friday from 2 pm to 7 pm or
Saturday from 8 am to 7 pm (if and only if you start on Sunday),
Sunday from 8 pm to 1 am (if and only if you start on Monday)
now 8pm to 1am seemed a bit unlikely to me, so i checked the French version
Quote
[VENDREDI 18 / SAMEDI 19 /
DIMANCHE 20 AOÛT 2023
retrait de votre dossier
le vendredi de 14h00 à 19h00
ou le samedi de 8h00 à 19h00 uniquement pour les partants du dimanche,
le dimanche de 8h00 à 13h00 uniquement pour les partants du lundi.
24 hour clock is less ambiguous, so you have until 13:00, that's 9 hours from your 4m arrival time to cover 180km. pretty tough if riding all loaded up for the event. I would be surprised if they allowed anyone to collect outside this window, or they will just end up with everyone turning up later. More chance of getting someone to collect for you.

That is pretty much exactly the gist of my question. I asked Thierry of ACP and he confirmed that I can ask a kind Monday starter who'll be there a bit earlier than me to pick up my bits and pieces on my behalf.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: αdαmsκι on 06 June, 2023, 07:24:32 pm
Have they published Brest cut off times yet? Or anyone care to share what they were last time around.
Specifically interested in the 84H rider's 600km allowance but having them all here in one place would be ace :)

2015 brevet card from 84 hr start

(https://i.ibb.co/dfqPSk0/IMG-20230606-192219.jpg) (https://ibb.co/p18fg4v)
(https://i.ibb.co/YTpLFJt/IMG-20230606-192155.jpg) (https://ibb.co/BKqC5vg)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ajax Bay on 06 June, 2023, 11:57:59 pm
Have they published Brest cut off times yet? Or anyone care to share what they were last time around.
Specifically interested in the 84H rider's 600km allowance but having them all here in one place would be ace :)

I can't remember what the control closing times were for PBP19 . . . .
Here's what LWaB said 4 years ago:
If you are a slow starter, the 84hr intermediate time limits are remarkably tight until just a few controls from the finish, at which point bags of time are gained each stage. The 'race out, tour back' advice kicks in much harder on the 84hr start than the 90hr IMHO.

EDIT: The minimum average speed required for the first 600km of a 84hr PBP is 16km/h (or thereabouts) and 12.7km/h for 600-1000km then 13.3km/h till the end, as per https://rusa.org/octime_rm.html
The minimum average for the 90hr starters is 15km/h for 600km, 11.5km/h-ish for 600-1000km, then 13.3km/h.
Remember that many slower folk want to sleep once in the first 600km of PBP but twice in the next 400km.

For me
1999, 2003 - 90hr solo, great fun, no time pressures at all, sub-70 and low-80 hour finishes.
2007, 2011 - 84hr solo, tighter on time than I'd hoped till well past Brest, sub-80 hour finishes.
2015 - 90hr tandem, great fun, no time pressures at all. Blast through the first night on adrenalin (and lots of sleep beforehand) and plenty of sleep every night after that, sub-90 hour finish.
2019 - same as 2015.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 07 June, 2023, 01:53:25 pm
I think at every time limit you get more time than you can possibly need to get from Mortagne au Perche to Rambouillet UNLESS you have a sleep at Dreux. I'm amazed anyone can finish at 89 hours+ without being out of time at earlier controls or deliberately stalling in the last couple of sections to join the Adrian Hands society. Meanwhile, it becomes very difficult to stay inside time first thing in the morning. I finished in 79 hours 20, but if I had been on the 80 hours schedule I would have been late at the first two controls on Tuesday and Wednesday morning.

I can't find the document we got in 2019 with all the time limits, was it emailed, or did we have to download something from the net? But this was my recollection.? Does no one have that still?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 07 June, 2023, 07:50:10 pm
I think at every time limit you get more time than you can possibly need to get from Mortagne au Perche to Rambouillet UNLESS you have a sleep at Dreux. I'm amazed anyone can finish at 89 hours+ without being out of time at earlier controls or deliberately stalling in the last couple of sections to join the Adrian Hands society.

Well, I did get close to this in 2015. The secret is a steady ride with little sleep (for me mostly 3-4 hours in total during PBP), and when I sleep, it's outside of the controls. A 90 hour rider starting relatively early will BTW be best suited sleeping between Mortagne and Dreux, especially for late sleepers.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: thing1 on 08 June, 2023, 08:22:02 pm
I think at every time limit you get more time than you can possibly need to get from Mortagne au Perche to Rambouillet UNLESS you have a sleep at Dreux. I'm amazed anyone can finish at 89 hours+ without being out of time at earlier controls or deliberately stalling in the last couple of sections to join the Adrian Hands society. Meanwhile, it becomes very difficult to stay inside time first thing in the morning. I finished in 79 hours 20, but if I had been on the 80 hours schedule I would have been late at the first two controls on Tuesday and Wednesday morning.

I can't find the document we got in 2019 with all the time limits, was it emailed, or did we have to download something from the net? But this was my recollection.? Does no one have that still?

Helpfully linked by LWaB here https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=112382.0
Unhelpfully the link is now dead
Helpfully wayback machine has that page here https://web.archive.org/web/20210225101110/http://www.paris-brest-paris.org/index2.php?lang=en&cat=inscription&page=dossier_participant
Unhelpfully they didn't index the zipped pdf file.

I think a friend still has a copy of it somewhere, will check.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: TOBY on 08 June, 2023, 08:41:36 pm
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1o26tewmqw4wvaC6jZfwhjaMGGn_tqwrE/view?usp=drivesdk

Page 20 onwards for 2019 control times


I think at every time limit you get more time than you can possibly need to get from Mortagne au Perche to Rambouillet UNLESS you have a sleep at Dreux. I'm amazed anyone can finish at 89 hours+ without being out of time at earlier controls or deliberately stalling in the last couple of sections to join the Adrian Hands society. Meanwhile, it becomes very difficult to stay inside time first thing in the morning. I finished in 79 hours 20, but if I had been on the 80 hours schedule I would have been late at the first two controls on Tuesday and Wednesday morning.

I can't find the document we got in 2019 with all the time limits, was it emailed, or did we have to download something from the net? But this was my recollection.? Does no one have that still?

Helpfully linked by LWaB here https://yacf.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=112382.0
Unhelpfully the link is now dead
Helpfully wayback machine has that page here https://web.archive.org/web/20210225101110/http://www.paris-brest-paris.org/index2.php?lang=en&cat=inscription&page=dossier_participant
Unhelpfully they didn't index the zipped pdf file.

I think a friend still has a copy of it somewhere, will check.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 09 June, 2023, 10:08:48 am
I think at every time limit you get more time than you can possibly need to get from Mortagne au Perche to Rambouillet UNLESS you have a sleep at Dreux. I'm amazed anyone can finish at 89 hours+ without being out of time at earlier controls or deliberately stalling in the last couple of sections to join the Adrian Hands society.

Well, I did get close to this in 2015. The secret is a steady ride with little sleep (for me mostly 3-4 hours in total during PBP), and when I sleep, it's outside of the controls. A 90 hour rider starting relatively early will BTW be best suited sleeping between Mortagne and Dreux, especially for late sleepers.
yes I guess if you have time for 10 hours sleep on the ride and you split it into 5 equally spaced rests of 2 hours it works, but that seems like a really uncomfortable way to ride to me.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 09 June, 2023, 10:18:13 am
I think at every time limit you get more time than you can possibly need to get from Mortagne au Perche to Rambouillet UNLESS you have a sleep at Dreux. I'm amazed anyone can finish at 89 hours+ without being out of time at earlier controls or deliberately stalling in the last couple of sections to join the Adrian Hands society.

Well, I did get close to this in 2015. The secret is a steady ride with little sleep (for me mostly 3-4 hours in total during PBP), and when I sleep, it's outside of the controls. A 90 hour rider starting relatively early will BTW be best suited sleeping between Mortagne and Dreux, especially for late sleepers.
yes I guess if you have time for 10 hours sleep on the ride and you split it into 5 equally spaced rests of 2 hours it works, but that seems like a really uncomfortable way to ride to me.

No, I didn't have time for 3-4 hours per night, I had time for about 1-1 1/2 hours per night, totalling at about 3-4 hours for the entire ride. For each his own, I'm not a rider with bursts of speed, but more a steady speed. And not only on my bike (I once did a 1500m PB in speed skating with the 3 full laps each within 0.5 seconds of each other).

Edit, got the data out of my best 3 1500m races (full lap times only)
35.6 36.5 37.0
36.0 36.3 36.8
35.7 35.5 36.1
(conventional wisdom is that anything with less then 2 seconds 'loss' per lap is good on a 1500)
So a lot has to do with how your body is functioning.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 09 June, 2023, 10:43:58 am
Honestly I don't think I could function on so little sleep, so I would be looking very hard at reducing every other stop to the bare minimum, to try to get more sleep. (you may already be efficient)

On a recent hilly 600, I only had time for one hours sleep and it was getting hard to stay awake at times. to do that for a second night, would leave me falling off the bike I think.

On LEL I had 2 hours at Hessle, 4 hours at Brampton, 5 hours at Dunfermline, 4 hours at Barnard Castle, only 2.5 hours at Boston due to the heat forecast and I was forced to nap twice between Boston and the finish
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 09 June, 2023, 11:51:39 am
Honestly I don't think I could function on so little sleep, so I would be looking very hard at reducing every other stop to the bare minimum, to try to get more sleep. (you may already be efficient)

On a recent hilly 600, I only had time for one hours sleep and it was getting hard to stay awake at times. to do that for a second night, would leave me falling off the bike I think.

On LEL I had 2 hours at Hessle, 4 hours at Brampton, 5 hours at Dunfermline, 4 hours at Barnard Castle, only 2.5 hours at Boston due to the heat forecast and I was forced to nap twice between Boston and the finish

the amount of sleep needed is very different from person to person.
For me, at a 600, all depends on the start time. If I've worked/travelled the day before, I need 1-2 hours when the start is before 6am, a little nap when the start is at 7am, and no sleep when the start is at 8 or 9am. Hence, I prefer a relatively late start.
When I have thursday/friday off, the amount of sleep needed decreases. But still I need some sleep when the start is at 6am or earlier.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Flâneur on 09 August, 2023, 08:49:10 pm
Helmet now compulsory? Email just dropped:

"Due to decisons of the french administration, we need to modify the PBP2023 regulations. Wearing a helmet becomes compulsory.

Article 9 of the regulations will be modified from  "It is highly recommended to wear an approved helmet throughout the event." to "It is requested by the french administration to wear an approved helmet throughout the event." The wearing of the helmet will be checked as well as the presence of the reflective vest and the conformity of your vehicle before entering the starting area. We remind you that it is not necessary to come with your bike to collect the documents."

The French version is "Le port du casque à coque rigide est rendu obligatoire tout au long du brevet par décision préfectorale.", which is clearly rather more than a request.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: iscunonove on 09 August, 2023, 09:34:58 pm
Begs the question: is there a penalty for failing to comply? If so, what?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 09 August, 2023, 09:38:43 pm
The English translation is sloppy, it's not the French Administration (Republican Level) but a few préfectures (local level) who apparantly required this. I haven't received the mail yet, but did see some screenshots.
From the point of view of adminsitrative law (speaking as a political scientist), it's very odd that a local official can deviate from national law. Usualy such decisions are revoked by a judge, but that takes time and effort.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 09 August, 2023, 10:03:50 pm
I hope somebody French makes a decent attempt to reverse this rule.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: αdαmsκι on 09 August, 2023, 10:08:13 pm
Feels a bit bloody late in the day to make this change. And I say this as someone who was going to wear a helmet regardless.

This is what the email says
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Von Broad on 09 August, 2023, 10:11:04 pm
Feels a bit bloody late in the day to make this change.

...especially when you haven't even got one!!!...
oh well....looks like I'm going to be out of time now regardless, with all the penalties coming my way :-)
A Royal PITA.....rebel!!!! It's what the French normally do, isn't it?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: αdαmsκι on 09 August, 2023, 10:26:15 pm
Can you even wear a helmet if riding a 'bent? Genuine question; I've no idea
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Von Broad on 09 August, 2023, 10:36:51 pm
Can you even wear a helmet if riding a 'bent? Genuine question; I've no idea
Plenty do......and plenty don't! - you've only got to look at the velo-special start to see that.
Depends on the bike as much as the rider with bents.

what's a right pita for me, is I've just spent ages building a [very shoddy] carbon tailbox for the trike, and got my head resting nicely on the front of it, as a head rest.......just where it needs to be!!!!! Nice. There's no way I'm shoving a helmet between and me and my DIY soot box.

I have a feeling that, if needs must, I will bring a helmet, and show it to the relevant politburo,.....then several miles down the road, all of a sudden, I get robbed and somebody nics it....because they also didn't have time to buy one before the event. Honest. Or something like that :-)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: mattc on 09 August, 2023, 11:13:22 pm
Feels a bit bloody late in the day to make this change.

...especially when you haven't even got one!!!...
oh well....looks like I'm going to be out of time now regardless, with all the penalties coming my way :-)
A Royal PITA.....rebel!!!! It's what the French normally do, isn't it?
I will source one for you to get thru registration, if you want!

I certainly don't intend to wear one on the ride; I have plenty of long LRM/BRM finishes on my palmares, nothing to prove here.

How should we rebel? The French do it so well ... perhaps a blockade of something or someone? Maybe set fire to some stuff?

I shall enjoy my ride, whatever, with or without brevet stamps medals etc. Allons y!
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 09 August, 2023, 11:29:05 pm
Can you even wear a helmet if riding a 'bent? Genuine question; I've no idea
Plenty do......and plenty don't! - you've only got to look at the velo-special start to see that.
Depends on the bike as much as the rider with bents.

what's a right pita for me, is I've just spent ages building a [very shoddy] carbon tailbox for the trike, and got my head resting nicely on the front of it, as a head rest.......just where it needs to be!!!!! Nice. There's no way I'm shoving a helmet between and me and my DIY soot box.

I have a feeling that, if needs must, I will bring a helmet, and show it to the relevant politburo,.....then several miles down the road, all of a sudden, I get robbed and somebody nics it....because they also didn't have time to buy one before the event. Honest. Or something like that :-)

Cut the back off a cheap helmet. Make sure the EU approval label is in the front half :p

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ian H on 09 August, 2023, 11:46:06 pm
Can you even wear a helmet if riding a 'bent? Genuine question; I've no idea
Plenty do......and plenty don't! - you've only got to look at the velo-special start to see that.
Depends on the bike as much as the rider with bents.

what's a right pita for me, is I've just spent ages building a [very shoddy] carbon tailbox for the trike, and got my head resting nicely on the front of it, as a head rest.......just where it needs to be!!!!! Nice. There's no way I'm shoving a helmet between and me and my DIY soot box.

I have a feeling that, if needs must, I will bring a helmet, and show it to the relevant politburo,.....then several miles down the road, all of a sudden, I get robbed and somebody nics it....because they also didn't have time to buy one before the event. Honest. Or something like that :-)

Cut the back off a cheap helmet. Make sure the EU approval label is in the front half :p

J
Exactly my thought.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Andy Corless on 10 August, 2023, 12:35:57 am
Glad I'm not going this time.  8)

Andy Corless
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LateStarter on 10 August, 2023, 01:28:48 am
A Royal PITA.....rebel!!!! It's what the French normally do, isn't it?

A Republican PITA surely , as long as they only burn motor vehicles and not bicycles.

The PBP organisers are in a difficult position if local officials have some cyclist’s headwear obsession as they need the support of those officials. It’s not my backyard so perhaps I should stay out of it but IMHO Europe has nothing positive to learn from long running Australian failed cycling regulation experiments (since early 1990s). Australian PBP participation peaked in 2007 and has declined every edition since and looks like it has declined again in 2023, I totally blame headwear but admit there might be other explanations.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Frank9755 on 10 August, 2023, 05:16:02 am
This is a pain.

On a practical level, I am concerned about the risk of getting Shermer's neck from doing a long ride with a helmet when I've not worn one all year. Neck muscles need to be trained to carry the additional weight.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: aidan.f on 10 August, 2023, 05:47:26 am
Quote
Cut the back off a cheap helmet. Make sure the EU approval label is in the front half :p
Before reading this I actually did that to an old helmet last night, much more comfortable. It's not that obvious , do you think I can get away with it?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 10 August, 2023, 05:47:50 am
I hope somebody French makes a decent attempt to reverse this rule.

The problem is that 2 years is a short term for a administrative judge, 10 days is an impossible timeframe for a administrative judge to rule about this.
Going the political way is also an issue in august, as none of the local parliaments will be in session.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: aidan.f on 10 August, 2023, 06:41:31 am
Now ordered three helmets in the hope one is comfortable enough. Not surprised that price and weight have no correlation.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Graeme on 10 August, 2023, 07:18:31 am
Oh bother.
Now looking for the lightest thing I can find.
Didn't need this additional cost
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Von Broad on 10 August, 2023, 07:56:10 am
I will source one for you to get thru registration, if you want!

Thanks for the offer Matt....I should be able to source something from a mate round here.

I shall enjoy my ride, whatever, with or without brevet stamps medals etc. Allons y!

Yes, I think this is the attitude. I could be struggling to get round in time anyway so it really doesn't make any odds.
I could do with a break anyway, that's for sure.

Cut the back off a cheap helmet. Make sure the EU approval label is in the front half :p

Good  thinking!
Really depends if the motorbike riders have been instructed to go into full Stasi mode when on patrol.....I can't see the controls being much of an issue.

I've still got plenty of cloth and epoxy left. Might wrap a layer of carbon cloth round my head, wrap it with some cling film, sleep on it and hey presto....nice light helmet in the morning! [the fact I won't be able to remove it might be an issue though!]

Wonder if my mother kept those Beatle masks I used to wear?
Might be able to do something with one of those  :)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: arabella on 10 August, 2023, 08:31:26 am
Seems a bit weird, presumably something brewing in the background for a while but ... if I'd purchased (which I haven't) <something> on the basis that (x, in this case x = optional helmet), and they changed the rules, I'd want my money back as they were no longer offering the <something> that I'd purchased.
YMMV, and there are probably weasel rules around this

Not to mention my risk profile says I'm safer without a helmet.  (mind you, mass event like PBP probably gives a different risk profile)

Definitely never doing PBP again.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Zed43 on 10 August, 2023, 08:46:26 am
Can you even wear a helmet if riding a 'bent? Genuine question; I've no idea
In my velomobile there's not enough space between my head and the headrest. It would drive my chin through my chest and on a distance like this result in a neck injury for sure.

I just sent an email to the PBP organisation but, as Ivo already told me, they may understand the issue but the prefect may not (even know about the existence of velomobiles).
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Graeme on 10 August, 2023, 08:47:41 am
Now ordered three helmets in the hope one is comfortable enough. Not surprised that price and weight have no correlation.

Just done the same thing. Ordered one MET, one Giro and one Kask because, like shoes, I guess each manufacturer uses a different mould. Will return the least-well-fitting two. Thankfully Merlin Cycles have some huge discounts. I'm mainly bothered that this is a last minute change to my riding which I'm unprepared for. I don't know how I'll get on with a splat-hat because I never wear one. Oh well, it's PBP and I've been excited about this for years, I guess I'll just have to do what I'm told.

Us casquetteurs are in a the minority aren't we. Rebelling just makes us look petty to all those who've never understood why we don't wear these magic hats.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Dai P on 10 August, 2023, 09:16:50 am
Ah!  In both my previous PBP rides I have got Shermer’s  neck, in 2007 only for the last 50k but in 2019 for the last 300k, the weight of the helmet made a huge difference and in 2019 I would not have been able to continue if wearing a helmet (also had a neck brace).  Does this mean if I get shermers neck again I have to withdraw, which I won’t obviously but will I suspect be docked time, fined or sent to jail.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: parkysouthlondon on 10 August, 2023, 09:58:35 am
The reason riders get Sherman’s neck is because they don’t sleep enough, not to do with the weight of the helmet on their head.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: The Bonk on 10 August, 2023, 10:13:55 am
The reason riders get Sherman’s neck is because they don’t sleep enough, not to do with the weight of the helmet on their head.

(https://imgtr.ee/images/2023/08/10/a4f274caffb5d2dd867087200113da0a.jpeg)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: arabella on 10 August, 2023, 10:33:55 am
The reason riders get Sherman’s neck is because they don’t sleep enough, not to do with the weight of the helmet on their head.
do you actually mean that or do you mean it's more likely to happen on a longer ride (duh!)
sleeping == giving your neck a rest from having to support the weight of a helmet (fuller value riders will get less chance to have such rests.)

Other thought sound is different if the waves do need to go around a helmet as opposed to if they don't - another thing to get used to

[it might be useful, perhaps (but I am not riding) to know in which admin areas helmets can/can't be removed]
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: aidan.f on 10 August, 2023, 10:40:15 am
Quote
Us casquetteurs are in a the minority aren't we. Rebelling just makes us look petty to all those who've never understood why we don't wear these magic hats.

I'm going to wear one but can someone here translate a plaquette for my saddlebag.

 " I am wearing a helmet under protest and deplore compulsion"

And I'm not wearing it for registration or around Rambouillet

Whatever your personal opinion IME YACF members support freedom of choice
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 10 August, 2023, 10:43:38 am
Whatever your personal opinion IME YACF members support freedom of choice

I wear a helmet when on my ride bike. I think making them mandatory is a stupid idea.

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: aidan.f on 10 August, 2023, 10:50:08 am
 :thumbsup:
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Frank9755 on 10 August, 2023, 11:25:18 am
The reason riders get Sherman’s neck is because they don’t sleep enough, not to do with the weight of the helmet on their head.

The causes of Shermer's are not completely understood but virtually everyone accepts weight on head is a contributory factor. Riding a long time is obviously the main thing, but amount of sleep per se hasn't got a lot to do with it, other than if you've slept more you are likely to have not ridden for as long.

The other main factors are
- the strength and fatigue tolerance of your core and your neck muscles, which you can improve through training - yoga, planks, getting used to the weight of a helmet
- position, how aggressive, time on aerobars, etc.

Before an event like TCR where I know in advance that I'll have to wear a helmet, I do specific training to get my neck muscles ready for it!
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Bikeabilityman on 10 August, 2023, 12:39:08 pm
This is a pain.

On a practical level, I am concerned about the risk of getting Shermer's neck from doing a long ride with a helmet when I've not worn one all year. Neck muscles need to be trained to carry the additional weight.
The only time I had Shermer’s Neck was from day three onwards on the 2014 Mille Cymru, and I’d been wearing helmets for over 20 years. I put it down to having my head down honking up the climbs, then being in the tuck position on the descents. After reading advice about it, I now have three helmets (the heaviest when I’m upright on my town bike, and the other two are 100g or more lighter for the road bikes), I take my helmet off on long rides whenever I can, and I massage the back of my neck when I ride. I’ve read about strength exercises, but I don’t do exercise, I just ride my bike 🤣. Not had neck issues since, but I was approached several times while volunteering at Louth last year as riders on LEL were suffering. Never wore inner tubes like Phil did 🤣
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: John Stonebridge on 10 August, 2023, 01:10:53 pm
Lots of riders leave stuff - including helmets - at controls. 

Did it myself in 2015 at Loudeac on the way back - and I was miles down the road before I realised.  In mitigation it was night and I had a buff covering my head otherwise I might have twigged instantly on departure. 

Guy at Tinteniac just laughed at me when asking if they had any casquettes (sold out monsieur) and it took a visit to a Decathlon in Fougeres some 150km later to restore a lid. 

It subsequently turned out that Id not got my brevet card stamped at Loudeac either so I must have been a bit gubbed.  When contacted by ACP afterwards I resisted the temptation to suggest they could use my left behind helmet (with my rider number on it) as valid proof of passage and instead accepted my 2 hr time penalty which took me up to 89h 54m though I believe the official record has me as 90hrs dead. 

Wonder if/how this will be policed this time.   Crazy to leave such a decision so late.  I can see it being reversed very late in the day or not actually policed - neither of which will be any use to folk who dont normally wear a helmet. 
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Plodder on 10 August, 2023, 01:58:29 pm
How should we rebel? The French do it so well ... perhaps a blockade of something or someone? Maybe set fire to some stuff?

Nowadays French protesters wear yellow vests, so don't forget to take one...  ;)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Wycombewheeler on 10 August, 2023, 02:04:52 pm
Oh bother.
Now looking for the lightest thing I can find.
Didn't need this additional cost
lighter should cost more, since all should meet the safety standards (such as they are)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Graeme on 10 August, 2023, 02:15:08 pm
Oh bother.
Now looking for the lightest thing I can find.
Didn't need this additional cost
lighter should cost more, since all should meet the safety standards (such as they are)

Merlin Cycles have some hefty discounts at the mo.
Ordered a few on credit, and will return all but the most comfortable one.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Lightning Phil on 10 August, 2023, 05:51:39 pm
The reason riders get Sherman’s neck is because they don’t sleep enough, not to do with the weight of the helmet on their head.

Isn’t it the tank pressing down on their head that causes that alternate condition?
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Lightning Phil on 10 August, 2023, 05:55:56 pm
Now ordered three helmets in the hope one is comfortable enough. Not surprised that price and weight have no correlation.
Us casquetteurs are in a the minority aren't we. Rebelling just makes us look petty to all those who've never understood why we don't wear these magic hats.

Not sure we are, but I doubt there is any unbiased data available on the subject.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Lightning Phil on 10 August, 2023, 06:22:36 pm
Can you even wear a helmet if riding a 'bent? Genuine question; I've no idea

Depends on the model and how reclined, whether the rider uses a head rest etc.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: mattc on 10 August, 2023, 07:02:52 pm
This is a pain.

On a practical level, I am concerned about the risk of getting Shermer's neck from doing a long ride with a helmet when I've not worn one all year. Neck muscles need to be trained to carry the additional weight.
I only have physics and anecdata to back this up, but I'm happy to believe that helmets+headtorches are the worst combination.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: quixoticgeek on 10 August, 2023, 07:17:55 pm

I only have physics and anecdata to back this up, but I'm happy to believe that helmets+headtorches are the worst combination.

I think there's a certain amount of positioning that's relevant here getting the light to closer to the centre of gravity of the head helps.

But yes. I have a helmet mount light for descending in the dark, but I rarely use it.

J
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 10 August, 2023, 07:21:14 pm
There's another item which greatly enhances the risk of Shermer's Neck, the kangaroo pouch. If loaded with all kinds of heavy stuff, like passport and coins, and then the cord pushing on one of the nerves in your neck, your muscles can give in.
I've seen this happening with other people, when the kangaroo pouch is removed, they miraculously recover in a few hours. (No 100% guarantee though)
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Dai P on 10 August, 2023, 10:01:22 pm
On LEL many year ago, I was pretty close to the end, Last controlI think, it was then dark, put on head torch and within a few minutes neck just dropped.  Whilst sleep is important, weight makes a big difference. Now doing neck exercises with old helmet and weights, as well as planks, so hopefully this year…………
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Pingu on 10 August, 2023, 11:24:05 pm
...Caps are so much nicer.

+1
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Mr Larrington on 10 August, 2023, 11:56:12 pm
This is a pain.

On a practical level, I am concerned about the risk of getting Shermer's neck from doing a long ride with a helmet when I've not worn one all year. Neck muscles need to be trained to carry the additional weight.
I only have physics and anecdata to back this up, but I'm happy to believe that helmets+headtorches are the worst combination.

Helmets and cameras are probably worse, especially if you actually crash, cf. M Schumacher.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: frillipippi on 11 August, 2023, 07:35:23 am
There's another item which greatly enhances the risk of Shermer's Neck, the kangaroo pouch. If loaded with all kinds of heavy stuff, like passport and coins, and then the cord pushing on one of the nerves in your neck, your muscles can give in.
I've seen this happening with other people, when the kangaroo pouch is removed, they miraculously recover in a few hours. (No 100% guarantee though)

My personal experience is that, when you start feeling your neck dangerously tired, if you remove all the stuff you have in your jersey pockets (and put it in some bag, tied to your bicycle instead of your body) the situation improves.

Always in my personal experience, the rougher the road surface is, the sooner Shermer's neck happens.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ian H on 11 August, 2023, 12:46:26 pm
Lots of riders leave stuff - including helmets - at controls. 

Did it myself in 2015 at Loudeac on the way back - and I was miles down the road before I realised.  In mitigation it was night and I had a buff covering my head otherwise I might have twigged instantly on departure. 

Guy at Tinteniac just laughed at me when asking if they had any casquettes (sold out monsieur) and it took a visit to a Decathlon in Fougeres some 150km later to restore a lid. 

It subsequently turned out that Id not got my brevet card stamped at Loudeac either so I must have been a bit gubbed.  When contacted by ACP afterwards I resisted the temptation to suggest they could use my left behind helmet (with my rider number on it) as valid proof of passage and instead accepted my 2 hr time penalty which took me up to 89h 54m though I believe the official record has me as 90hrs dead. 

Wonder if/how this will be policed this time.   Crazy to leave such a decision so late.  I can see it being reversed very late in the day or not actually policed - neither of which will be any use to folk who dont normally wear a helmet.

I was asked if I'd forgotten my helmet when exiting a control somewhere, whatever year it was.  My negative reply seemed to confuse them.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: postie on 11 August, 2023, 02:28:42 pm
Ian you normally confuse your self and baffle the rest of us ;D
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ian H on 11 August, 2023, 05:26:57 pm
Ian you normally confuse your self and baffle the rest of us ;D

Careful, I might come and ride one of your events.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LateStarter on 13 August, 2023, 06:44:50 am
The “updated” date on The “Rules” says 12th August. The English version equipment section now says,

“ It is requested by the french administration to wear an approved helmet throughout the event”

The French section translates to something stronger,

“The wearing of a hard shell helmet is made mandatory throughout the patent by prefectural decision” (Apple Translate)
"Wearing a hard-shell helmet is made compulsory throughout the patent by prefectural decision." (Google Translate)

The pre start check-in section (both English & French) still only mentions checking of lights & vest.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: grams on 13 August, 2023, 09:50:44 am
The updated English rule saying "recommended" and the French saying "obligatoire" is exactly what was in the email.

That email also introduced the change with the word "compulsory". I don't think you can pretend the intention isn't clear. The best hope is another last minute rule change or at least some exceptions being added.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Ivo on 13 August, 2023, 10:38:10 am
In the international world, the original language usually is the valid version, everything else is just for convenience. So hair-splitting should be reserved for the French text.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Flatlander on 19 August, 2023, 08:24:27 pm
I assume the photo bit is optional as was said above otherwise the admin would have wanted one at sign in. I only rembered about it when i opened the brevet.

Has anyone filled in the medical / 3rd party insurance stuff in the brevet card? NHS number or eqiv is a bit lost on me. Asking so I can stop worrying.

Would have checked on the PBP website but it appears to be down. Who would want to look at such things on a Saturday night whan they should be in a bar😁?


Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Frank9755 on 19 August, 2023, 09:01:56 pm
I don't have a pen and am not too worried about it.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: mattc on 28 August, 2023, 09:46:19 pm
I don't have a pen and am not too worried about it.

  :o how did you plan to fill out your Infos?!?

Anyway, plastic hat updates:
At least two of us only wore them at the start (to avoid hassles), and finished without any serious challenge.
The latest official photo shows me sans casque  O:-)

Of course there may yet be a post-mortem enquiry, but we have our medals, completed brevet cards (and tracker screenshots :⁠-⁠P )

The few AUK helmet evangelists can kiss my calloused arse.

(At least) some down-wrong riders were officially exempted.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: LittleWheelsandBig on 28 August, 2023, 09:50:38 pm
Good work mattc. I capitulated and complained and I turned into little puddles of lard each afternoon. The maximum temperatures may not have sounded too high but they sure felt it.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Zed43 on 29 August, 2023, 08:37:52 am
I did email Jean-Gualbert Faburel (the international contact of ACP, and rider A001...) beforehand and got a reply that the volunteers would be informed that a helmet is not required in a velomobile because the risk of head injury is neglectable compared to riding a regular bike.

Well, not all volunteers got the message... Passing through Mortagne the "man with the whistle" said I should wear a helmet, but let me pass when I replied (in rehearsed French phrases  ;)) that this was not required for velomobiles. Forty kilometers later the two motards who stopped me were not to be convinced, not even by reading Faburel's email. After 15 minutes driving with a helmet (I did bring one to avoid discussions) my neck started to hurt and I ditched it. On the German velomobile forum I know of one person who got stopped twice and even got threatened with a time penalty (he couldn't care less, finishing in 70 hours).

Not a word about helmets when I had a chat with three motards of the Gendarmerie Nationale in Pontivy at 760km.
 
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: Graeme on 29 August, 2023, 12:09:57 pm
I called into the Medical Centre at Fougères on the way out, and told them I had a sore neck. I asked for a medical exemption certificate. Cunning eh.

They offered me a medical exemption certificate but said that I would be disqualified if I used it. I'm not sure they understood what a medical exemption certificate is for. Not so cunning after all. Also, in all the rush to get a hat before the ride, it turns out I got the fit wrong. I'm really disappointed in the last minuteness of the change, giving me no time to prepare. Anyway, what's done is done. I'll get a better fit for 2027 - meanwhile back to the joy of caps.
Title: Re: PBP 2023 - Rulz
Post by: mattc on 29 August, 2023, 12:22:33 pm
I read the Penalty List again - it says something like "noone can be stopped from riding" for any penalty (although this is contradicted for lights  :facepalm: )
So you should always be able to finish the brevet.

I haven't completely confirmed Ricki Goode's protest ride yet. He told me he would register - to get a wristband for stuffs - then start solo (no lid!) and thus on a Private Excursion, before the 90h groups. He has no times on the tracker, and I heard he abandoned quite early.

Top man  :thumbsup: